Retropubic Operations for Stress Urinary Incontinence

4 Retropubic Operations for Stress Urinary Incontinence





Introduction


Since 1949, when Marshall et al. first described retropubic urethrovesical suspension for the treatment of stress urinary incontinence (SUI), retropubic procedures have proved to be consistently curative. Although numerous terminologies and variations of retropubic repairs have been described, the basic goal remains the same: to suspend and to stabilize the anterior vaginal wall, and with it the bladder neck and proximal urethra, in a retropubic position. This suspension prevents the descent of these structures and allows urethral compression against a stable suburethral layer. Selection of a retropubic approach (vs. a vaginal approach) depends on many factors, such as the need for laparotomy or laparoscopy for other pelvic prolapse or disease, amount of pelvic organ prolapse, status of the intrinsic urethral sphincter mechanism, age and health status of the patient, history of previous sling or mesh complications, desires of future fertility, preference and expertise of the surgeon, and preferences of an informed patient.


Historically, there were few data to differentiate one retropubic procedure from another. The three most studied and popular retropubic procedures were the Burch colposuspension, the Marshall-Marchetti-Krantz (MMK) procedure, and the paravaginal defect repair. I prefer the Burch colposuspension for urodynamic SUI with bladder neck hypermobility and adequate resting urethral sphincter function, and sometimes combine it with a paravaginal defect repair when the patient has stage 2 or 3 anterior vaginal prolapse or when a concurrent sacrocolpopexy is to be done. The surgical techniques described in this chapter are contemporary modifications of the original operations. Tanagho (1976) described the modified Burch colposuspension. The paravaginal defect repair was described by Richardson et al. (1981) and Shull and Baden (1989) (paravaginal repair) and by Turner-Warwick (1986) and Webster and Kreder (1990) (vaginal obturator shelf repair). Although less critically studied, the paravaginal defect repair, until more recently, was regionally popular and widely performed in the United States. The operations described do not represent one correct technique but a commonly used and proven method.


This chapter describes only retropubic suspension procedures that use an abdominal wall incision for direct access into the space of Retzius. The use of laparoscopy and mini-incision laparotomy to enter the retropubic space and perform these and similar procedures is possible and occasionally preferred. The decision to use laparoscopy and mini-incision laparotomy usually is based on whether other concurrent surgeries need to be done and on what is most desired by the surgeon and the informed patient. The reader is referred to Surgical Management of Pelvic Organ Prolapse (Karram and Maher, 2012) in the Female Pelvic Surgery Video Atlas series for a thorough critique of the use of operative laparoscopy for urinary incontinence and prolapse.




Case 1: Stress Urinary Incontinence and Large Uterine Fibroids


A 46-year-old, para 3 woman complains of heavy painful menstrual periods, pelvic pressure, and bothersome urine loss with coughing and exercise. She states that she has been diagnosed with uterine fibroids in the past, but her symptoms are worse this year. Pelvic examination reveals a 16-week-size globular mobile uterus and no other pelvic masses. On vaginal examination, she has stage 1 anterior vaginal wall prolapse with urethral hypermobility. She has no uterine or posterior vaginal wall prolapse and good levator muscle function during voluntary pelvic muscle squeeze. She has no history of abnormal Papanicolaou (Pap) smears and had a normal Pap test and human papillomavirus screen 1 year earlier. On office urodynamics evaluation, she is examined with a full bladder in the supine position and noted to leak urine with coughing from the urethra. She voided 360 mL and had a catheterized post-void residual urine volume of 20 mL. Her urinalysis is negative.


Discussion of treatment options includes conservative and medical management of uterine fibroids and menorrhagia and conservative management with physical therapy for SUI. She states that she has been bothered by both problems for many years, has previously not improved with hormone therapy and Kegel exercises, and is now interested in definitive therapy including a hysterectomy. She also notes that she would prefer not to have mesh placed during the reconstructive surgery unless absolutely necessary.


After discussing all of the options for routes of hysterectomy and for treatment of SUI, it was decided that the patient would undergo an open total abdominal hysterectomy, Burch colposuspension, and cystoscopy using a Pfannenstiel incision. After the hysterectomy was completed, she would have reattachment of her uterosacral ligaments to the vaginal cuff. This treatment was accomplished without complication.



Indications for Retropubic Procedures


Retropubic urethrovesical suspension procedures are indicated for women with a diagnosis of urodynamic SUI and a hypermobile proximal urethra and bladder neck. Although midurethral slings are usually performed as first-line surgical treatment for these patients, Burch colposuspension remains an option because studies have shown similar efficacy to slings. In patients who do not wish to have surgery that uses synthetic mesh, Burch colposuspension and fascial slings are the best options. Retropubic procedures usually are not used for intrinsic sphincter deficiency with urethral hypermobility because other, more obstructive operations such as a retropubic bladder neck or midurethral sling are likely to yield better long-term results.


To diagnose urodynamic SUI, clinical and urodynamics (simple or complex) testing must be performed to evaluate bladder filling, storage, and emptying (see Chapter 2). Abnormalities of bladder-filling function, such as detrusor overactivity, can coexist with urethral sphincter incompetence in 30% of patients and may be associated with a lower cure rate after retropubic surgery.


Women with SUI generally should have a trial of conservative therapy before corrective surgery is offered. Conservative treatments include pelvic muscle exercises, bladder retraining, pharmacologic therapy, and mechanical devices such as pessaries. Eligible and willing postmenopausal patients with atrophic urogenital changes should be prescribed vaginal estrogen before surgery is considered.



Surgical Techniques



Operative Setup and General Entry into the Retropubic Space




1. The patient is supine, with the legs supported in a slightly abducted position, allowing the surgeon to operate with one hand in the vagina and the other in the retropubic space. The vagina, perineum, and abdomen are sterilely prepared and draped in a fashion that permits easy access to the lower abdomen and vagina.


2. A three-way 16F or 20F Foley catheter with a 20- to 30-mL balloon is inserted in a sterile fashion into the bladder and kept in the sterile field. The drainage port of the catheter is left to gravity drainage, and the irrigation port is connected to sterile water with or without blue dye.


3. One perioperative intravenous dose of an appropriate antibiotic should be given as prophylaxis against infection within 1 hour before the incision is made.


4. A Pfannenstiel incision is usually the preferred type of skin incision. Entrance into the retropubic space sometimes may be facilitated by using a Cherney incision (Figure 4-1). During intraperitoneal surgery, the peritoneum is opened, the surgery is completed, and the cul-de-sac is plicated, if necessary.


5. The retropubic space is exposed. Staying close to the back of the pubic bone, the surgeon’s hand is introduced into the retropubic space and the bladder and urethra are gently moved downward (Figure 4-2). Sharp dissection usually is not necessary in primary cases. To aid visualization of the bladder, 100 mL of sterile water with methylene blue or indigo carmine dye may be instilled into the bladder after the catheter drainage port is clamped.


6. If previous retropubic or other bladder neck suspension procedures have been performed, dense adhesions from the anterior vaginal and bladder wall and urethra to the symphysis pubis are often present. These adhesions should be dissected sharply from the pubic bone until the anterior bladder wall, urethra, and vagina are free of adhesions and are mobile. If identification of the urethra or lower border of the bladder is difficult, one may perform a cystotomy, which, with a finger inside the bladder, helps to define the lower limits of the bladder for easier dissection, mobilization, and elevation (Figure 4-3).






Technique for Burch Colposuspension (Video 4-1 image)




1. After the retropubic space is entered, the urethra and anterior vaginal wall are depressed. No dissection should be performed in the midline over the urethra or at the urethrovesical junction, protecting the delicate musculature of the urethra from surgical trauma. Attention is directed to the tissue on either side of the urethra. The surgeon’s nondominant hand is placed in the vagina, palm facing upward, with the index and middle fingers on each side of the proximal urethra. Most of the overlying fat should be cleared away, using a swab mounted on a curved forceps sponge stick. This dissection is accomplished with forceful elevation of the surgeon’s vaginal finger until glistening white periurethral fascia and vaginal wall are seen (Figure 4-4). This area is extremely vascular, with a rich, thin-walled venous plexus that should be avoided, if possible. The position of the urethra and the lower edge of the bladder is determined by palpating the Foley balloon and by partially distending the bladder to define the rounded lower margin of the bladder as it meets the anterior vaginal wall.


2. When dissection lateral to the urethra is completed and vaginal mobility is judged to be adequate by using the vaginal fingers to lift the anterior vaginal wall upward and forward, sutures are placed. No. 0 or 1 delayed absorbable or nonabsorbable sutures are placed as far laterally in the anterior vaginal wall as is technically possible. We apply two sutures of No. 0 braided polyester on an SH needle (Ethibond; Ethicon, Inc, Somerville, NJ) bilaterally, using double bites for each suture. The distal suture is placed approximately 2 cm lateral to the proximal third of the urethra. The proximal suture is placed approximately 2 cm lateral to the bladder wall at or slightly proximal to the level of the urethrovesical junction. In placing the sutures, one should take a full thickness of vaginal wall, excluding the epithelium, with the needle parallel to the urethra (Figure 4-5). This maneuver is best accomplished by suturing over the surgeon’s vaginal finger at the appropriate selected sites. On each side, after the two sutures are placed, they are passed through the pectineal (Cooper) ligament so that all four suture ends exit above the ligament. Before the sutures are tied, a 1 × 4 cm strip of absorbable gelatin sponge (Gelfoam) may be placed between the vagina and obturator fascia below the Cooper ligament to aid adherence and hemostasis.


3. As noted previously, this area is extremely vascular, and visible vessels should be avoided if possible. When excessive bleeding occurs, it can be controlled by direct pressure, sutures, or vascular clips. Less severe bleeding usually stops with direct pressure and after tying the suspension sutures.


4. After all four sutures are placed in the vagina and through the Cooper ligaments, the assistant ties first the distal sutures and then the proximal ones, while the surgeon elevates the vagina with the vaginal hand. In tying the sutures, one does not have to be concerned about whether the vaginal wall meets the Cooper ligament, so one should not place too much tension on the vaginal wall. A suture bridge is usually found between the two points. After the sutures are tied, one can easily insert two fingers between the pubic bone and the urethra, preventing compression of the urethra against the pubic bone. Vaginal fixation and urethral support depend more on fibrosis and scarring of periurethral and vaginal tissues over the obturator internus and levator fascia than on the suture material itself (see Video 6-1 image).





Paravaginal Defect Repair (Video 4-2 image)


The object of the paravaginal defect repair is to reattach, bilaterally, the anterolateral vaginal sulcus with its overlying endopelvic fascia to the pubococcygeus and obturator internus muscles and fascia at the level of the arcus tendineus fasciae pelvis.


May 29, 2016 | Posted by in GASTOINESTINAL SURGERY | Comments Off on Retropubic Operations for Stress Urinary Incontinence

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access