Infections of the Urinary Tract

Anthony J. Schaeffer, MD, Edward M. Schaeffer, MD, PhD




Urinary tract infections (UTIs) are common, affect men and women of all ages, and vary dramatically in their presentation and sequelae. They are a common cause of morbidity and can lead to significant mortality. Although the urinary tract is normally free of bacterial growth, bacteria that generally ascend from the rectal reservoir may cause UTIs. When bacterial virulence increases or host defense mechanisms decrease, bacterial inoculation, colonization, and infection of the urinary tract occur. Careful diagnosis and treatment result in successful resolution of infections in most instances. A better understanding of the pathogenesis of UTIs and the role of host and bacterial factors has improved the ability to identify patients at risk and prevent or minimize sequelae. Clinical manifestations can vary from asymptomatic bacterial colonization of the bladder to irritative symptoms such as frequency and urgency associated with bacterial infection; upper tract infections associated with fever, chills, and flank pain; and bacteremia associated with severe morbidity, including sepsis and death. New antimicrobial agents that achieve high urinary and tissue levels, that can be administered orally, and that are not nephrotoxic have significantly reduced the need for hospitalization for severe infection. Shorter-course therapy and prophylactic antimicrobial agents have reduced the morbidity and cost associated with recurrent cystitis in women. Although the vast majority of patients respond promptly and are cured by therapy, early identification and treatment of patients with complicated infections that place them at significant risk remains a clinical challenge to urologists.



Definitions


UTI is an inflammatory response of the urothelium to bacterial invasion that is usually associated with bacteriuria and pyuria.


Bacteriuria is the presence of bacteria in the urine, which is normally free of bacteria. It has been assumed to be a valid indicator of either bacterial colonization or infection of the urinary tract. Although this is usually true, studies in animals (Hultgren et al, 1985; Mulvey et al, 1998) and humans (Elliott et al, 1985) have indicated that bacteria may be in the urothelium in the absence of bacteriuria. Alternatively, bacteriuria may represent bacterial contamination of an abacteriuric specimen during collection.


The possibility of contamination increases as the reliability of the collection technique decreases from suprapubic aspiration to catheterization to voided specimens. The term significant bacteriuria has a clinical connotation and is used to describe the number of bacteria in a suprapubically aspirated, catheterized, or voided specimen that exceeds the number usually caused by bacterial contamination of the skin, the urethra, or the prepuce or introitus, respectively. Hence it represents a UTI.


Bacteriuria can be symptomatic or asymptomatic. When it is detected by population studies (screening surveys), screening bacteriuria is a more precise and descriptive term than asymptomatic bacteriuria, especially because the latter term is clinically useful for describing the presence or absence of symptoms in an individual patient.


Pyuria, the presence of white blood cells (WBCs) in the urine, is generally indicative of infection and an inflammatory response of the urothelium to the bacterium. Bacteriuria without pyuria is generally indicative of bacterial colonization without infection of the urinary tract. Pyuria without bacteriuria warrants evaluation for tuberculosis, stones, or cancer.


Infections are often defined clinically by their presumed site of origin.


Cystitis describes a clinical syndrome of dysuria, frequency, urgency, and occasionally suprapubic pain. These symptoms, although generally indicative of bacterial cystitis, may also be associated with infection of the urethra or vagina or noninfectious conditions such as interstitial cystitis, bladder carcinoma, or calculi. Conversely, patients may be asymptomatic and have infection of the bladder and possibly the upper urinary tract.


Acute pyelonephritis is a clinical syndrome of chills, fever, and flank pain that is accompanied by bacteriuria and pyuria, a combination that is reasonably specific for an acute bacterial infection of the kidney. The term should not be used if flank pain is absent. It may have no morphologic or functional components detectable by routine clinical modalities. There may be serious difficulties in diagnosing spinal cord–injured and elderly patients who may be unable to localize the site of their discomfort.


Chronic pyelonephritis describes a shrunken, scarred kidney, diagnosed by morphologic, radiologic, or functional evidence of renal disease that may be postinfectious but is frequently not associated with UTI. Bacterial infection of the kidney may cause a focal, coarse scar in the renal cortex overlying a calyx, almost always accompanied by some calyceal distortion (Fig. 10–1), which can be detected radiographically or by gross examination of the kidney. Less commonly, renal scarring from infection can result in atrophic pyelonephritis or generalized thinning of the renal cortex, with a small kidney appearing radiographically similar to one with postobstructive atrophy (Fig. 10–2).



image

Figure 10–2 A, Excretory urogram of the contralateral left kidney from the same patient as in Figure 10–1. The severe pyelonephritic atrophy, undoubtedly caused by febrile urinary infections during early infancy with reflux into different segments of the kidney, produced irregular cortical scarring. Note how all the calyces extend to the capsule with irregular, intervening areas of cortex. B, Pyelonephritic atrophy, suggestive of postobstructive atrophy, in a 20-year-old woman with spina bifida, neurogenic bladder, and many episodes of fever and bacteriuria in early childhood. Observe the uniform, regular atrophy of the renal cortex that suggests reflux of bacteria simultaneously into virtually all nephrons. This type of pyelonephritic atrophy is uncommon compared with that shown in A and is characteristic of obstruction with superimposed infection.


UTIs may also be described in terms of the anatomic or functional status of the urinary tract and the health of the host.


Uncomplicated describes an infection in a healthy patient with a structurally and functionally normal urinary tract. The majority of these patients are women with isolated or recurrent bacterial cystitis or acute pyelonephritis, and the infecting pathogens are usually susceptible to and eradicated by a short course of inexpensive oral antimicrobial therapy.


A complicated infection is associated with factors that increase the chance of acquiring bacteria and decrease the efficacy of therapy (Table 10–1). The urinary tract is structurally or functionally abnormal, the host is compromised, and/or the bacteria have increased virulence or antimicrobial resistance. The majority of these patients are men.


Table 10–1 Factors That Suggest Complicated UTI


















Reprinted from Schaeffer AJ. Urinary tract infections. In: Gillenwater JY et al, editors. Adult and pediatric urology. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2002. p. 212.


Renal diseases that reduce the concentrating ability of the kidney or neurologic conditions that alter bladder-emptying capabilities are commonly encountered functional abnormalities.


Examples of anatomic abnormalities include obstruction associated with calculi or enlargement of the prostate or congenital or acquired sites of residual urine, such as calyceal or bladder diverticula. A complicated infection is frequently caused by bacteria that have exposure to many antimicrobial agents.


Chronic is a poor term that should be avoided in the context of UTIs, except for chronic pyelonephritis or bacterial prostatitis, because the duration of the infection is not defined.


UTIs may also be defined by their relationship to other UTIs:





The term reinfection describes a new event associated with reintroduction of bacteria into the urinary tract from outside.


Bacterial persistence refers to a recurrent UTI caused by the same bacteria reemerging from a focus within the urinary tract, such as an infectious stone or the prostate. Relapse is frequently used interchangeably. These definitions require careful clinical and bacteriologic assessment and are important because they influence the type and extent of the patient’s evaluation and treatment.


Antimicrobial prophylaxis is the prevention of reinfections of the urinary tract by the administration of antimicrobial drugs. If the term is used correctly in reference to the urinary tract it can be assumed that bacteria have been eliminated before prophylaxis is begun. Surgical antimicrobial prophylaxis entails administration of an antimicrobial agent before and for a limited time after a procedure to prevent local or systemic postprocedural infections.


Antimicrobial suppression is the prevention of growth of a focus of bacterial persistence that cannot be eradicated. A low, nightly dosage of an antimicrobial agent usually results in the urine showing no growth, as in the case of a small infectious stone or in bacterial prostatitis caused by Escherichia coli. Suppressive is also a useful term when recurrent acute symptoms are prevented in a poor-risk patient, such as one with a large staghorn calculus in whom the antimicrobial agent reduces but does not eliminate the bacteria in the urine.


Domiciliary or outpatient UTIs occur in patients who are not hospitalized or institutionalized at the time they become infected. The infections are generally caused by common bowel bacteria (e.g., Enterobacteriaceae or Enterococcus faecalis), which are susceptible to most antimicrobial agents.


Nosocomial or health care–associated UTIs occur in patients who are hospitalized or institutionalized, and these are typically caused by Pseudomonas and other more antimicrobial-resistant strains.




Incidence and Epidemiology


UTIs are considered to be the most common bacterial infection. They account for more than 7 million visits to physicians’ offices and necessitate or complicate over 1 million office visits and 1 million emergency department visits, resulting in 100,000 hospitalizations annually (Patton et al, 1991, Hooton and Stamm, 1997; Foxman et al, 2000). They account for 1.2% of all office visits by women and 0.6% of all office visits by men (Schappert, 1997).


The overall prevalence of bacteriuria in women has been estimated at 3.5%, with prevalence generally increasing with age in a linear trend (Evans et al, 1978). Surveys screening for bacteriuria have shown that about 1% of schoolgirls (aged 5 to 14 years) (Kunin et al, 1962) have bacteriuria and that this figure increases to about 4% by young adulthood and then by an additional 1% to 2% per decade of age (Fig. 10–3). Nearly 30% of women will have had a symptomatic UTI requiring antimicrobial therapy by age 24, and almost half of all women will experience a UTI during their lifetime. The prevalence of bacteriuria in young women is 30 times more than in men. However, with increasing age, the ratio of women to men with bacteriuria progressively decreases. At least 20% of women and 10% of men older than 65 years have bacteriuria (Boscia and Kaye, 1987; Juthani-Mehta, 2007).



The incidence of bacteriuria also increases with institutionalization or hospitalization and concurrent disease (Sourander, 1966). In a study of women and men older than 68 years, Boscia and Kaye (1987) found that 24% of functionally impaired nursing home residents had bacteriuria compared with 12% of healthy domiciliary subjects (Boscia et al, 1986). UTIs account for approximately 38% of the 2 million nosocomial infections each year (Sedor and Mulholland, 1999; Lo et al, 2008). More than 80% of nosocomial UTIs are secondary to an indwelling urethral catheter (Sedor and Mulholland, 1999). The incidence of UTIs is also increased during pregnancy and in patients with spinal cord injuries, diabetes, multiple sclerosis, and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS).


The financial impact of community-acquired UTIs is nearly $1.6 billion in the United States alone (Foxman, 2002); the annual cost of nosocomial UTIs has been estimated to range from between $515 million and $548 million (Jarvis, 1996).


Little is known about the natural history of untreated bacteriuria in women because most women are treated when they are diagnosed, but a few studies in which treatment with antimicrobial agents is compared with placebo have been done. These show that 57% to 80% of bacteriuric women who are untreated or treated with placebo clear their infections spontaneously (Mabeck, 1972; Guttmann, 1973). Mabeck (1972) found that 8 of 53 bacteriuric women placed on placebo needed treatment with an antimicrobial agent because of symptoms, but 32 of the remaining 45 women cleared without treatment within a month, and 43 of the 45 had spontaneously cleared of bacteriuria within 5 months; only 2 women remained persistently bacteriuric.


Once a patient has an infection, he or she is likely to develop subsequent infections. Many adults had UTIs as children, underscoring the importance of genotypic factors in UTIs (Gillenwater et al, 1979). Of 45 women with untreated UTIs whose infection cleared, 20 (46%) had recurrences within a year (Mabeck, 1972).


When women with recurrent bacteriuria were observed after treatment, about one sixth (37 of 219) had a very high recurrence rate (2.6 infections per year) whereas the remaining women had a recurrence rate of only 0.32 per year (Mabeck, 1972). Similar separation was seen in a prospective study in which only 28.6% of 60 women who experienced their first symptomatic UTI had recurrent infections over the first 18 months of observation, as opposed to recurrences in 82.5% of 106 women who had had previous UTIs (Harrison et al, 1974). Other investigators also have found that the probability of recurrent UTIs increases with the number of previous infections and decreases in inverse proportion to the elapsed time between the first and the second infections (Mabeck, 1972). Of these recurrent infections, 71% to 73% are caused by reinfection with different organisms, rather than recurrence with the same organism (Mabeck, 1972; Guttmann, 1973).


Women with frequent reinfections have a rate of 0.13 to 0.25 UTIs per month (1.6 to 3.1 infections per year) when the infections are treated with antimicrobial agents (Mabeck, 1972; Guttmann, 1973; Kraft and Stamey, 1977; Vosti, 2002).


In a prospective long-term study of 235 women with more than 1000 confirmed infections studied over a period ranging from 1 to nearly 20 years, about half of the patients had clusters of infections, which ranged in frequency from 2 to 12 infections per cluster. Infections were followed by remission-free intervals that averaged approximately 1 year. Most reinfections occurred after 2 weeks (Harrison et al, 1974) and within 5 months (Mabeck, 1972), and most occurred early in this interval (Kraft and Stamey, 1977; Vosti, 2002) (Fig. 10–4). Rates of reinfection were independent of bladder dysfunction, radiologic changes of chronic pyelonephritis, and vesicoureteral reflux (Guttmann, 1973). The reinfections did not occur evenly over time. In the Stanford series (Kraft and Stamey, 1977), 23 women with frequent recurrent infections were studied with monthly urine cultures when asymptomatic and with immediate cultures when symptomatic for cystitis, for a mean of 3 years. Thirty-four percent of infections were followed by infection-free intervals of at least 6 months (average, 12.8 months), and 22 of the 23 women had such intervals. However, even these long intervals were followed by further infections (Kraft and Stamey, 1977), thus underscoring the importance of genotypic factors in the pathogenesis of UTIs in women (Schaeffer et al, 1981).



When the Stanford data (Kraft and Stamey, 1977) on recurrent UTIs in highly susceptible females are analyzed by examining sets of infections separated by remissions of at least 6 months, 69% of the sets contain only one infection. After this first set, the remaining sets show a 33% remission rate in infections, which means a patient who has two or more infections within 6 months has only a 33% probability of remaining free of infection for the next 6 months. Therefore, if antimicrobial prophylaxis is started after the second or any succeeding infection within a set, about two thirds of the women will benefit.


Whether a patient receives no treatment at all or short-term, long-term, or prophylactic antimicrobial treatment the risk of recurrent bacteriuria remains the same; prophylactic antimicrobial therapy reduces reinfections but does not alter the underlying predisposition to recurring infection. Asscher and associates (1973) found that reinfections occurred in 17 patients (34%) treated with a 7-day course of nitrofurantoin and in 13 patients (29%) receiving placebo during a 3- to 5-year follow-up. Mabeck (1972) found that 46% (20 of 43) of untreated patients had recurrent infections by 12 months compared with about 40% of treated patients who had recurrences. Both studies suggest that it makes little difference whether a UTI is cured with an antimicrobial agent or is allowed to clear spontaneously—the susceptibility to recurrent UTI remains the same. Moreover, patients with frequent UTI who take prophylactic antimicrobial agents for extended periods (≥6 months) may decrease their infections during the time of prophylaxis but the rate of infection returns to the pretreatment rate after prophylaxis is stopped (Vosti, 1975; Stamm et al, 1980a). Even long interruptions in the pattern of recurrence, therefore, do not appear to alter the patient’s basic susceptibility to infections.


The sequelae of complicated UTIs are substantial. It is well established in the presence of obstruction, infection stones, diabetes mellitus, and other risk factors that UTIs in adults can lead to progressive renal damage (Freedman, 1975). The long-term effects of uncomplicated recurrent UTIs are not completely known, but, so far, no association between recurrent infections and renal scarring, hypertension, or progressive renal azotemia has been established (Asscher et al, 1973; Freedman, 1975). Indeed, one investigator was unable to find a single case of unequivocal nonobstructive chronic pyelonephritis in 22 patients in whom chronic pyelonephritis was the cause of end-stage renal failure (Schechter et al, 1971). Similar data were reported by Huland and Busch (1982).


In pregnant women the prevalence and rate of recurrent infection are the same but their bacteriuria progresses to acute clinical pyelonephritis more frequently than in nonpregnant women. This variation in the natural history of recurrent infections in females is discussed in a later section on UTIs in pregnancy.




Pathogenesis


UTIs are a result of interactions between the uropathogen and the host. Successful infection of the urinary tract is determined in part by the virulence factors of the bacteria, the inoculum size, and the inadequacy of host defense mechanisms. These factors also play a role in determining the ultimate level of colonization and damage to the urinary tract. Whereas increased bacterial virulence appears to be necessary to overcome strong host resistance, bacteria with minimal virulence factors are able to infect patients who are significantly compromised.



Routes of Infection



Ascending Route


Most bacteria enter the urinary tract from the bowel reservoir via ascent through the urethra into the bladder. Adherence of pathogens to the introital and urothelial mucosa plays a significant role in ascending infections. This route is further enhanced in individuals with significant soilage of the perineum with feces, women who use spermicidal agents (Hooton et al, 1996; Foxman, 2002; Handley et al, 2002), and patients with intermittent or indwelling catheters.


Although cystitis is often restricted to the bladder, approximately 50% of infections can extend into the upper urinary tract (Busch and Huland, 1984). The weight of clinical and experimental evidence strongly suggests that most episodes of pyelonephritis are caused by retrograde ascent of bacteria from the bladder through the ureter to the renal pelvis and parenchyma. Although reflux of urine is probably not required for ascending infections, edema associated with cystitis may cause sufficient changes in the ureterovesical junction to permit reflux. Once the bacteria are introduced into the ureter, they may ascend to the kidney unaided. However, this ascent would be greatly increased by any process that interferes with the normal ureteral peristaltic function. Gram-negative bacteria and their endotoxins, as well as pregnancy and ureteral obstruction, have a significant antiperistaltic effect.


Bacteria that reach the renal pelvis can enter the renal parenchyma by means of the collecting ducts at the papillary tips and then ascend upward within the collecting tubules. This process is hastened and exacerbated by increased intrapelvic pressure from ureteral obstruction or vesicoureteral reflux, particularly when it is associated with intrarenal reflux.






Fastidious Organisms



Anaerobes in the Urinary Tract


Although symptomatic anaerobic infections of the urinary tract are documented, they are uncommon. However, the distal urethra, perineum, and vagina are normally colonized by anaerobes. Whereas 1% to 10% of voided urine specimens are positive for anaerobic organisms (Finegold, 1977), anaerobic organisms found in suprapubic aspirates are much more unusual (Gorbach and Bartlett, 1974). Clinically symptomatic UTIs in which only anaerobic organisms are cultured are rare, but these organisms must be suspected when a patient with bladder irritative symptoms has cocci or gram-negative rods seen on microscopic examination of the centrifuged urine (catheterized, suprapubic aspirated, or voided midstream urine) and routine quantitative aerobic cultures fail to grow organisms (Ribot et al, 1981).


Anaerobic organisms are frequently found in suppurative infections of the genitourinary tract. In one study of suppurative genitourinary infections in males, 88% of scrotal, prostatic, and perinephric abscesses included anaerobes among the infecting organisms (Bartlett and Gorbach, 1981). The organisms found are usually Bacteroides species, including B. fragilis, Fusobacterium species, anaerobic cocci, and Clostridium perfringens (Finegold, 1977). The growth of clostridia may be associated with cystitis emphysematosa (Bromberg et al, 1982).





Bacterial Virulence Factors


Virulence characteristics play a role in determining both if an organism will invade the urinary tract and the subsequent level of infection within the urinary tract. It is generally believed that uropathogenic strains resident in the bowel flora, such as uropathogenic E. coli (UPEC), can infect the urinary tract not only by chance but also by the expression of virulence factors that enable them to adhere to and colonize the perineum and urethra and migrate to the urinary tract where they establish an inflammatory response in the urothelium (Schaeffer et al, 1981; Yamamoto et al, 1997; Schlager et al, 2002; Moreno et al, 2008). The same virulence factors can be found on bacterial strains that cause recurrent UTI in patients (Foxman et al, 1995). Some of these virulence determinants are located on one of approximately 20 UPEC-specific pathogenicity-associated islands ranging from 30 to 170 kb (Hacker, 1999; Oelschlaeger et al, 2002). These pathogenicity islands collectively increase the size of the pathogen genome by about 20% over a commensal strain. A recent genomic analysis of a UPEC strain revealed the presence of genes for putative chaperone-usher systems as well as autotransporter proteins that may function as adhesins, toxins, proteases, invasins, serum resistance factors, or motility mediators (Henderson and Nataro, 2001). One UPEC-specific autotransporter, Sat, seems toxic to urinary tract cells in vitro (Guyer et al, 2000) and can cause cytoplasmic vacuolation and severe histologic damage in mouse kidneys (Guyer et al, 2002). Another toxin, hemolysin HlyA, forms pores in a variety of host cell membranes (Uhlen et al, 2000). In addition to proteases and toxins, UPEC produces several iron acquisition systems, including aerobactin (Johnson et al, 1988; Johnson, 2003) and the more recently described IroN system (Russo et al, 1999; Sorsa et al, 2003). Lastly, most UPEC strains produce an acid polysaccharide capsule that protects the bacteria from phagocytosis by human polymorphonuclear leukocytes and inhibits activation of complement (Johnson, 2003).



Early Events in UPEC Pathogenesis



Bacterial Adherence


Bacterial adherence to vaginal and urothelial epithelial cells is an essential step in the initiation of UTIs. This interaction is influenced by the adhesive characteristics of the bacteria, the receptive characteristics of the epithelial surface, and the fluid bathing both surfaces. Bacterial adherence is a specific interaction that plays a role in determining the organism, the host, and the site of infection. Portions of this section on bacterial adherence have been published (Schaeffer et al, 1981).



Bacterial Adhesins


UPEC expresses a number of adhesins that allow it to attach to urinary tract tissues (Mulvey, 2002). These adhesins are classified as either fimbrial or afimbrial, depending on whether the adhesin is displayed as part of a rigid fimbria or pilus (Fig. 10–5). Bacteria may produce a number of antigenically and functionally different pili on the same cell; others produce a single type; in some, no pili are seen (Klemm, 1985). A typical piliated cell may contain 100 to 400 pili. The pilus is usually 5 to 10 nm in diameter, is up to 2 µm long, and appears to be composed primarily of subunits known as pilin (Klemm, 1985). Pili are defined functionally by their ability to mediate hemagglutination of specific types of erythrocytes. The most well-described pili are types 1, P, and S.




Type 1 (Mannose Sensitive) Pili


Type 1 pili are commonly expressed on both nonpathogenic and pathogenic E. coli. Type 1 pili consist of a helical rod composed of repeating FimA subunits joined to a 3-nm wide distal tip structure containing the adhesin FimH (Jones et al, 1995). These pili mediate hemagglutination of guinea pig erythrocytes (Duguid et al, 1979). The reaction is inhibited by the addition of mannose; thus type 1 pili are termed mannose-sensitive hemagglutination (MSHA) (Svenson et al, 1984; Reid and Sobel, 1987).


The role of type 1 pili as a virulence factor in UTIs has been established. This evidence has been obtained (1) from the analysis of bacteria isolated from the urine of patients with UTIs, which were found to express mannose-sensitive (MS) adhesins (Ljungh and Wadstrom, 1983); (2) from studies with animal models (Fader and Davis, 1982; Hagberg et al, 1983a, 1983b; Iwahi et al, 1983; Hultgren et al, 1985) in which inoculation of type 1 piliated organisms into the bladder resulted in significantly more colonization of the urinary tract than inoculation of nonpiliated organisms; and (3) from the observation that anti-type 1 pili antibodies and competitive inhibitors such as methyl-α-D-mannopyranoside protected mice from contracting UTIs (Aronson et al, 1979; Hultgren et al, 1985). Recent studies have demonstrated that interactions between FimH and receptors expressed on the luminal surface of the bladder epithelium are critical for the ability of many UPEC strains to colonize the bladder and cause disease (Connell et al, 1996; Langermann et al, 1997; Thankavel et al, 1997; Mulvey et al, 1998).


P (Mannose Resistant) Pili. P pili confer tropism to the kidney, the designation “P” standing for pyelonephritis (Mulvey, 2002). P pili, which are found in most pyelonephritogenic strains of UPEC, mediate hemagglutination of human erythrocytes that is not altered by mannose and is thus termed mannose-resistant hemagglutination (MRHA) (Kallenius et al, 1979). The adhesin PapG, at the tip of the pilus, recognizes the α-D-galactopyranosyl-(1-4)-β-D-galactopyranoside moiety present in the globoseries of glycolipids (Kallenius et al, 1980; Leffler and Svanborg-Eden, 1980), which are found on P-blood group antigens and on uroepithelium (Svenson et al, 1983).


The MRHA adhesins of UPEC that do not show the digalactoside-binding specificity have been provisionally named X adhesins (Vaisanen et al, 1981). In some strains of UPEC, hemagglutination is mediated by nonpiliated adhesins or hemagglutinins (Duguid et al, 1979).


Svanborg-Eden and coworkers (1978) were the first to report a correlation between bacterial adherence and severity of UTIs. They showed that UPEC strains from girls with acute pyelonephritis had high adhesive ability whereas strains causing asymptomatic bacteriuria or from the feces of healthy girls had low bacterial adherence. Between 70% and 80% of the pyelonephritic strains, but only 10% of the bowel isolates, had adhesive capacity. Furthermore, P pili were present in 91% of urinary strains causing pyelonephritis, 19% of strains causing cystitis, and 14% of strains causing asymptomatic bacteriuria but only 7% of bowel isolates from healthy children, highlighting the correlation between bacterial adherence and UTIs (Kallenius et al, 1981).


Whereas MRHA and P pili are strongly associated with pyelonephritis, these virulence factors are not associated with renal scarring and reflux due to bacterial infection (Vaisanen et al, 1981). Studies suggest minimal correlation between P-piliated E. coli strains and recurrent pyelonephritis with gross reflux in girls (Lomberg et al, 1983). Thus it would appear that P pili in acute pyelonephritis are important mainly in nonrefluxing or minimally refluxing children.




Phase Variation of Bacterial Pili in Vivo


Early evidence for the role of type 1 and P pili in adherence in UTIs in humans was contradictory. Pili were visible by electron microscopy on E. coli in the urine of 31 of 37 patients (Ljungh and Wadstrom, 1983). Conversely, no MS adhesins were found in 22 of 24 urine isolates from patients with indwelling catheters (Ofek et al, 1981), and 19 of 20 samples from patients with acute UTIs were devoid of pili and nonadherent until subcultured in broth (Harber et al, 1982). Assessment of pili production by clinical E. coli isolates demonstrates that environmental growth conditions can produce rapid changes in pilus expression (Duguid et al, 1966; Goransson and Uhlin, 1984; Hultgren et al, 1986), wherein cells switch back and forth between piliated and nonpiliated phases (Eisenstein, 1981). For example, some bacteria grown in a broth medium express pili whereas the same strain grown on the same medium in a solid state will cease production of pili. This process, called phase variation, can also occur in vivo and has obvious biologic and clinical implications. For example, the presence of type 1 pili may be advantageous to the bacteria for adhering to and colonizing the bladder mucosa but disadvantageous because the pili enhance phagocytosis and killing by neutrophils (Silverblatt et al, 1979).


An animal model of ascending UTIs and studies of bacterial isolates from different sites in patients with UTI provide evidence that phase variation can occur during E. coli UTI in vivo. Type 1 piliated E. coli organisms that were capable of phase variation were introduced into the mouse bladder in the piliated phase, and the bacteria recovered from the bladder and urine 24 or more hours after inoculation were tested for piliation. All of the animals had bladder colonization, and 78% of the bacteria recovered showed type 1 piliation. The bacteriologic state of the urine often differed from that of the bladder. The urine was sterile in 59% of the animals with bladder colonization, and the organisms recovered from the urine were often nonpiliated.


When bladder and kidney cultures were examined 1, 3, and 5 days after intravesical inoculation of piliated bacteria, organisms recovered from the bladder remained piliated, whereas organisms recovered from the kidney showed significantly less piliation (Schaeffer et al, 1987) (Fig. 10–6).



Studies in humans using indirect immunofluorescence of fresh urine bacteria have confirmed in-vivo expression and phase variation of pili. Analysis of the urine of adults with lower UTI detected type 1 pili in 31 of 41 specimens and P pili in 6 of 18 specimens (Kisielius et al, 1989). The piliation status of the bacterial population in the urine was heterogeneous, varying from predominantly piliated to a mixture of piliated and nonpiliated cells (Fig. 10–7). Strains isolated from different sites in the urogenital tract showed variation in the state of piliation. These results demonstrate that type 1 and P pili are expressed and subject to phase variation in vivo during acute UTIs.



This process of phase variation has obvious biologic and clinical implications. For example, the presence of type 1 pili may be advantageous to the bacteria for initially adhering to and colonizing the bladder mucosa. Subsequently, type 1 pili may be unnecessary for strains in suspension in urine and in fact detrimental because they enhance apoptosis, phagocytosis, and killing by neutrophils (Silverblatt et al, 1979; Mulvey et al, 1998). In the kidney, P pili may then take over as the primary mediator of bacterial attachment by means of their binding to the glycolipid receptors (Stapleton et al, 1995).



Epithelial Cell Receptivity



Vaginal Cells


The significance of epithelial cell receptivity in the pathogenesis of ascending UTI has been studied initially by examining adherence of E. coli to vaginal epithelial cells and uroepithelial cells collected from voided urine specimens. Fowler and Stamey (1977) established that certain indigenous microorganisms (e.g., lactobacilli, S. epidermidis) avidly attached themselves to washed epithelial cells in large numbers. When vaginal epithelial cells were collected from patients susceptible to reinfection and compared with such cells obtained from controls resistant to UTI, the E. coli strains that cause cystitis adhered much more avidly to the epithelial cells from the susceptible women. These studies established increased adherence of pathogenic bacteria to vaginal epithelial cells as the first demonstrable biologic difference that could be shown in women susceptible to UTI.


Subsequently, Schaeffer and colleagues (1981) confirmed these vaginal differences in women, but in addition they observed that the increased bacterial adherence was also characteristic of buccal epithelial cells. As can be seen in Figure 10–8, there is a striking similarity in the ability of both cell types to bind to the same E. coli strain. In addition, there was a significant relationship between vaginal cell and buccal cell receptivity. Seventy-seven different E. coli strains were tested for their ability to bind to vaginal and buccal epithelial cells. A direct nonlinear relationship between buccal and vaginal adherence in controls and patients was confirmed for urinary, vaginal, and anal isolates. Thus high vaginal cell receptivity was associated with high buccal cell receptivity.



These observations emphasize that the increase in receptor sites for UPEC on epithelial cells from women with recurrent UTIs is not limited to the vagina and thus suggest that a genotypic trait for epithelial cell receptivity may be a major susceptibility factor in UTIs. This concept was extended by examining the human leukocyte antigens (HLAs), which are the major histocompatibility complex in humans and have been associated statistically with many diseases (Schaeffer et al, 1983). The A3 antigen was identified in 12 (34%) of the patients, which is significantly higher than the 8% frequency observed in healthy controls. Thus HLA-A3 may be associated with increased risk of recurrent UTIs.



Variation in Receptivity


A small variation in both vaginal cell and buccal cell receptivity may be observed from day to day in healthy controls. Adherence ranges from 1 to 17 bacteria per cell and appears to be both cyclic and repetitive. When adherence was correlated with the days of a woman’s menstrual cycle, higher values were noted in the early phase, diminishing shortly after the time of expected ovulation (day 14). The number of bacteria per epithelial cell often correlated with the value obtained on the same day of the menstrual cycle 1 or 2 months previously. Premenopausal women are particularly susceptible to attachment of uropathogenic E. coli and nonpathogenic lactobacilli at certain times during the menstrual cycle and to E. coli during the early stages of pregnancy. The importance of such hormones as estrogens in the pathogenesis of UTI is therefore a matter of great interest, especially because the clinical urologist may see women who have recurrent cystitis at regular intervals, possibly in response to these hormonal changes.


Reid and Sobel (1987) found that uropathogens attached in larger numbers to uroepithelial cells from women older than 65 years of age than to cells from premenopausal women 18 to 40 years of age. Raz and Stamm (1993) noted that susceptibility to recurrent UTI was increased by the lowered estrogen levels found in the postmenopausal women and that estrogen replacement decreased uropathogenic bacterial colonization and the incidence of UTI.


Blood group antigens and carbohydrate structures bound to membrane lipids or proteins also constitute an important part of the uroepithelial cell membrane. The presence or absence of blood group determinants on the surface of uroepithelial cells may influence an individual’s susceptibility to a UTI. Sheinfeld and associates (1989) determined the blood group phenotypes in women with recurrent UTI and compared them with those of age-matched women controls. Women with Lewis Le(a−b−) and Le(a+b−) phenotypes had a significantly higher incidence of recurrent UTIs than women with Le(a−b+) phenotypes. There was no significant difference in the distribution of ABO or P blood group phenotypes. The Lewis antigen controls fucosylation. The protective effect in women with the Le(a−b+) phenotype may be due to fucosylated structures at the vaginal cell surface or in the overlying mucus, which decreases availability of putative receptors for E. coli (Navas et al, 1993). The nonsecretor status has also been associated with female acute uncomplicated pyelonephritis, especially in premenopausal women (Ishitoya et al, 2002). Stapleton and coworkers (1995) have shown that unique E. coli-binding glycerides are found in vaginal epithelial cells from nonsecretors but not from secretors. These studies individually and collectively support the concept that there is an increased epithelial receptivity for E. coli on the introital, urethral, and buccal mucosa that is characteristic of women susceptible to recurrent UTIs and may be a genotypic trait.


The possibility that vaginal mucus might influence bacterial receptivity was investigated by Schaeffer and colleagues (1994). Type 1 piliated E. coli bound to all of the vaginal fluid specimens (Venegas et al, 1995). The binding capacity of vaginal fluid from women colonized with E. coli in vivo was greater than that from noncolonized women (Schaeffer, 1999). The importance of vaginal fluid in bacteria/epithelial cell interactions was investigated in an in-vitro model that measured the effect of vaginal fluid on the binding of bacteria to an epithelial cell line (Gaffney et al, 1995). Vaginal fluid from colonized women enhanced binding of bacteria to epithelial cells. Conversely, vaginal fluid from noncolonized women inhibited adherence. Thus the vaginal fluid appears to influence adherence to cells and, presumably, vaginal mucosal colonization. Subsequent studies demonstrated that secretory IgA is the primary glycoprotein responsible for vaginal fluid receptivity (Rajan et al, 1999).


Jun 4, 2016 | Posted by in ABDOMINAL MEDICINE | Comments Off on Infections of the Urinary Tract

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access