Both glomerular and metabolic diseases can recur after transplantation, with most recurrences caused by glomerular disease. The most common causes of recurrence in children are discussed next.
Glomerular Diseases
FSGS is the most common cause of graft loss due to recurrent disease (
14). In patients whose original disease were steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome or confirmed FSGS, the disease recurs in 30% to 40% of patients undergoing primary transplantation; when the first transplant was lost to recurrence, FSGS recurs in 50% to 80% of those undergoing subsequent transplantation (
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23). The NAPRTCS database
has found that grafts in approximately 20% to 30% of patients with the diagnosis of FSGS fail because of recurrence. In patients with the original disease of FSGS whose grafts fail, the mean time to failure is 17 months.
Recurrence is usually characterized by massive proteinuria, hypoalbuminemia, and often the full-blown picture of nephrotic syndrome with edema or anasarca and hypercholesterolemia. It may present immediately or weeks to months after transplantation. Predictors of recurrence include rapid progression to ESRD from the time of initial diagnosis (less than 3 years) (
13,
20,
24,
25), poor response to therapy, younger age at diagnosis (but older than 6 years of age), black race, and presence of mesangial proliferation in the native kidney (
22,
24,
26,
27). In recent years, a protein permeability factor has been isolated from sera of patients with FSGS, and its concentration was found to correlate with recurrence and severity of disease in the transplanted kidney (
28). The precise nature of this factor remains unclear, and there is no clinically approved assay (
29,
30).
Early posttransplant recognition of recurrent FSGS is important because plasmapheresis (which may lower the serum levels of protein permeability factor), and/or high-dose calcineurin inhibitor may lead to significant reduction in graft losses due to recurrent FSGS. In vitro studies using rat glomeruli have shown that cyclosporine or tacrolimus, incubated with sera from FSGS patients, will inhibit the proteinuric effect of such sera. Thrice daily cyclosporine may be used in doses that maintain whole blood trough levels by Fluorescence polarization immunoassay (FPIA) or Enzyme multiplied immunoassay technique (EMIT) of between 200 and 400 ng/mL or higher and is tapered slowly after achieving remission of the nephrotic syndrome and as cholesterol concentration decreases, or if significant toxicity develops. Some centers have used high-dose continuous intravenous (IV) cyclosporine with similar improvement. Still others have used high-dose or thrice daily tacrolimus. Each of these has been associated with remission. Cyclophosphamide has been found to induce remission by some investigators. Finally, in limited experience, sirolimus has been suggested to be effective in preventing recurrence. This is based only on anecdotal data, and, paradoxically, similarly anecdotal data have suggested that new onset FSGS may occur when calcineurin inhibitors are stopped and sirolimus begun. Plasmapheresis is generally used with a frequency that matches disease severity and is occasionally required on a weekly basis for prolonged periods.
Living related donor transplant recipients have been reported in some studies to suffer from a higher rate of recurrence. Recent registry data from NAPRTCS has also suggested that the graft outcome in recipients of living donor grafts with FSGS recurrence is no better than the outcome observed in recipients of deceased donor grafts that have not experienced recurrence. These data have led many pediatric transplant centers to reduce or discontinue the use of living related donation in patients with FSGS. However, the controlled settings of live donor transplantation may allow certain benefit in patients with FSGS recurrence. Living donation may dramatically reduce the incidence of post-transplant DGF. In the setting of FSGS recurrence, it is important to avoid delayed graft function so that the dose of cyclosporine or tacrolimus can be augmented. In addition, the preplanning implicit in living donation permits preoperative and early postoperative plasmapheresis. Our experience suggests that this approach may prevent or decrease the severity of recurrent disease, but this approach must be tested in a controlled clinical trial. Thus, at our center, the potential for recurrence of FSGS is not regarded as a contraindication to living donor transplantation.
Alport syndrome.
Alport syndrome, or hereditary glomerulonephritis, is a progressive disease often associated with neurosensory hearing loss and ocular abnormalities such as anterior lenticonus and cataracts. Its inheritance pattern can be X-linked, autosomal recessive, and autosomal dominant. The abnormality in almost all patients stems from mutations in the α3, 4, or 5 helices of type 4 collagen. In over 80% of patients, Alport syndrome results from mutations in the COL4A5 gene on the X chromosome.
Strictly speaking, Alport syndrome itself does not recur; however, antiglomerular basement membrane (anti-GBM) glomerulonephritis may occur in approximately 3% to 4% of patients after transplantation and lead to graft loss. The antibodies causing the anti-GBM nephritis are usually directed against the α5 chain of the noncollagenous portion of type IV collagen in the GBM, but antibodies against the α3 chain have also been described. The risk appears to be greatest in patients with mutations of COL4A5 that prevent synthesis of the α5 chain.
Anti-GBM glomerulonephritis presents as rapidly progressive crescentic glomerulonephritis with linear deposits of IgG along the basement membrane and most commonly leads to graft loss. It usually occurs in the first posttransplant year, but does not have to occur in the early posttransplant period. Asymptomatic cases with linear IgG deposits have also been reported. Fortunately, this complication is rare and affects only 3% to 4% of recipients with Alport syndrome. Treatment consists of plasmapheresis and cyclophosphamide, but such treatment is of only limited benefit. Retransplantation is associated with a high recurrence rate.
Membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis.
Histological evidence of recurrence of membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (MPGN) type I varies widely, with reported rates from 20% to 70%. Graft loss occurs in up to 30% of cases (
31). There is no proven treatment for recurrence of MPGN I in children. Anecdotal case reports describe success with high-dose corticosteroids, mycophenolate mofetil, or plasma exchange.
Histological recurrence of type II disease occurs in virtually all cases. However, often this recurrence is benign without causing graft dysfunction or loss. Some studies suggest that graft loss from recurrent MPGN II may be as high as 30% to 50% of cases (
32,
33). In the 2000 NAPRTCS database, 78 patients with MPGN II received allografts and 24
(13%) of these grafts failed at a mean time posttransplant of 29 months. Ten (42%) of these grafts failed because disease recurred. Presence of crescents in the native kidney may predict severe recurrence that often leads to graft loss. As with MPGN I, plasmapheresis, mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) and high-dose corticosteroids have been reported to be beneficial in a few cases of recurrent type II disease.
IgA Nephropathy and Henoch-Schönlein Purpura.
Histological recurrence with mesangial IgA deposits is common and occurs in about half of patients with IgA nephropathy and in about 30% of patients with Henoch-Schönlein purpura (
34,
35,
36,
37,
38). Most of the recurrences are asymptomatic, but graft loss may occur, often associated with crescent formation. Data from adult centers suggest that a fulminant presentation of IgA nephropathy as the original cause of ESRD predicts poor outcome in the transplanted kidney with disease recurrence. In the NAPRTCS database, only 5% to 8% of graft failures were due to recurrence in patients with IgA nephropathy or Henoch-Schönlein purpura nephritis.
Hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS).
HUS accounts for 2.5% to 4.5% of primary renal disease in children leading to ESRD. In children, the most frequent form of HUS is diarrhea-associated (D+), or “typical,” and is caused by verotoxin-producing E. coli (VTEC). This is the most common form of HUS in childhood, but it results in ESRD in only 10% of cases. “Atypical” HUS is far less frequent in children. This group of entities is characterized by a prodrome that lacks diarrheal association (i.e., “D-”), a relapsing course, and a very poor renal prognosis.
When considering transplantation in patients whose original cause of ESRD was HUS, care must be directed to the form of HUS that the patient suffered. The diarrhea-associated, or “typical,” form does not usually recur after transplantation, while atypical HUS has a high propensity for recurrence. However, there are pitfalls in assessing recurrence of HUS. The D+/D− terminology can sometimes be misleading. Occasionally, patients with VTEC-associated HUS do not have diarrhea and therefore may be mistakenly labeled as D−. Similarly, diarrhea disease can trigger HUS in a patient who is genetically predisposed to HUS, and therefore erroneously be characterized as D+ HUS. In addition, it has been known for decades that it may be difficult to distinguish humorally mediated vascular rejection from recurrent HUS, which presents histologically as thrombotic microangiopathy (TMA). Finally, the calcineurin inhibitors cyclosporine and tacrolimus have occasionally caused TMA in the transplanted kidney. In some of these cases there is a clinical picture that resembles HUS. Despite these caveats, it is reasonable to conclude that D+ HUS has a recurrence rate of <1%, while the recurrence rate in D− HUS ranges from 20% to 25% (
39,
40,
41,
42,
43).
A review of the literature in VTEC-associated D+ HUS in children suggests that not only is the recurrence rate surpassingly small, but that renal transplantation in children with this disease is not associated with an increased incidence of allograft failure. The use of cyclosporine in these D+ patients is also not associated with a triggering of HUS recurrence.
When the literature is reviewed in case of HUS without diarrheal prodrome, recurrence occurs in 5% to 50% of patients with an aggregate recurrence rate of 21% of patients. It had been previously recommended that at least 1 year of clinical quiescence occur before transplantation was attempted in patients with D− HUS. However, recent experience suggests that a prolonged interval between initial HUS and transplantation does not reduce the risk of recurrence. It is difficult to ascertain the effect of calcineurin inhibition on recurrence of D− HUS (
44); avoidance of cyclosporine or tacrolimus did not prevent recurrence and graft loss in 2 children with this condition. The patient and graft outcome in recurrent atypical HUS is poor. Ten percent have died and 83% have lost the graft. In patients who have experienced recurrence, it is estimated that HUS will recur in approximately 50% of subsequent grafts.
Atypical HUS can be further subdivided based on the condition’s pathogenesis or genetics. It has recently been shown that a genetic defect of complement factor H production is associated with a severe form of D− HUS. Factor H deficiency induces continuous complement activation resulting in low C3 and C4 levels. While there are only a few cases of this condition in pediatric renal transplantation, this form of D− HUS appears to have an associated rate of recurrence of >50%. High-dose fresh frozen plasma with plasma exchange has been advocated in this condition. Recently, liver transplantation or combined liver/kidney transplantation has also been successful in a limited number of patients; the rationale for these approaches is that factor H is synthesized in the liver. The recurrence rate in the few reported patients with factor H gene mutations but normal factor H concentrations appears to be markedly less than those with factor H deficiency.
In children with D− HUS and a presumed autosomal recessive inheritance, the risk of recurrence appears to exceed 60%. This risk is as high in children as it is in adults. The use of cyclosporine or the type of donor (living-related donor vs. deceased donor) does not appear to affect the rate of recurrence. In patients with putative autosomal dominant form of D− HUS, the recurrence rate appears to be similar to those with autosomal recessive D− HUS (
44).
The problem with the diagnosis and management recurrent HUS is made even more challenging by the clinical entity of TMA that may accompany the use of cyclosporine, tacrolimus and other immunosuppressive agents in some patients. Other rarer causes in the posttransplant patient may include valacyclovir, viral infections such as parvovirus, HIV, and possibly cytomegalovirus (CMV), and antibodies against the von Willebrand factor-cleaving metalloproteinase ADAMTS13.
In calcineurin-associated TMA, pathological features may be localized only to the kidney without evidence of hemolysis or thrombocytopenia in >50% of cases. TMA in this situation typically presents shortly after starting treatment with cyclosporine or tacrolimus, but can occur at any time after transplantation. This form of TMA manifests
with a decline in urine output, a decrease in the rate of decline in serum creatinine, or an elevated serum creatinine level, with or without hematuria or proteinuria. Because of the nonspecific clinical course, a renal biopsy may be necessary to confirm the diagnosis. The most important aspects of therapy are stopping the calcineurin inhibitor and starting plasmapheresis/fresh frozen plasma in addition to augmenting the rejection prophylaxis regimen to compensate for the discontinuation of the calcineurin inhibitor. Restarting cyclosporine or tacrolimus after recovery of the graft function has been reported to be successful but with recurrent TMA rates of 20% to 30%. In some series, substitution of cyclosporine for tacrolimus (or
vice versa) has been successful.
Living donor transplantation is not contraindicated in patients whose original disease was D+ HUS. On the other hand, living donor transplantation is not advocated for patients with D− HUS. This is because of the high recurrence rate in such patients. In addition, it has been noted that some parental carriers of D− HUS might not manifest the disease until later in life, and organ donation would put such carriers at excessive risk.
Antiglomerular basement membrane disease.
Anti-GBM disease is rare in children. A high level of circulating anti-GBM antibody before transplantation is thought to be associated with a higher rate of recurrence. Therefore, a waiting period of 6 to 12 months with an undetectable titer of anti-GBM antibody is recommended before transplantation to prevent recurrence. Reappearance of anti-GBM antibody in the serum may be associated with histologic recurrence. Histological recurrence has been reported in up to half of cases, with clinical manifestations of nephritis in only 25% of these cases. Graft loss is rare, and spontaneous resolution may occur.
Congenital nephrotic syndrome.
Congenital nephrotic syndrome occurs in the first 3 months of life. It can be classified as either congenital nephrotic syndrome of the Finnish type (CNSF) or diffuse mesangial sclerosis (DMS).
CNSF is an autosomal recessive disease that occurs as a result of a mutation in the
NPHS 1 gene. While it is most commonly seen in Finnish patients, it is also found in other countries (
45). The
NPHS 1 gene is located on chromosome 19 and has as its gene product the protein nephrin. Nephrin is a transmembrane protein, which is a member of the immunoglobulin family of cell adhesion molecules. It is characteristically located at the slit diaphragms of the glomerular epithelial foot processes. More than 50 mutations of
NPHS 1 have been identified in CNSF, but over 90% of all Finnish patients have one of two mutations—the so called “Fin major and Fin minor” mutations.
Infants with CNSF are usually born prematurely and exhibit low birth weight and placentomegaly. CNSF manifests as heavy proteinuria, edema, and ascites, often in the first week of life and always by 3 months of age. Untreated, these children suffer from malnutrition, poor growth, frequent infections and thromboembolic complications. ESRD occurs invariably in mid childhood. Corticosteroids do not ameliorate CNSF, but in mild forms, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibition together with indomethacin may be successful (
46,
47). The best therapeutic success has come from the approach of early dialysis, nephrectomy, and transplantation.
CNSF does not recur after transplantation. However, de novo nephrotic syndrome has been reported in approximately 25% of cases. It presents with proteinuria, hypoalbuminemia, and edema that may start immediately or as late as 3 years after transplantation. All of the patients with posttransplant nephrotic syndrome have been reported to have the homozygous Fin major genotype. Antibodies against fetal glomerular structures are found in the majority of patients with posttransplant nephrotic syndrome, and antibodies to nephrin are found in over 50% (
48). Approximately half of patients with this nephrotic syndrome respond to steroids and cyclophosphamide, but in those who do not respond, the graft is usually lost (
49). Within the NAPRTCS database, vascular thrombosis and death with a functioning graft (mostly due to infectious complications) occur in 26% and 23% of cases, respectively, and account for higher rate of graft failure in this particular group.
DMS can be found in isolated form or as part of Denys-Drash syndrome. The latter is a syndrome composed of progressive renal disease with nephrotic syndrome and DMS, Wilms tumor, and male pseudohermaphroditism. Most patients with DMS have been found to have mutations of the WT-1 gene located on chromosome 11p13 (
50,
51). Patients with DMS who have received kidney transplants have not been observed to develop nephrotic syndrome.
Membranous nephropathy.
Recurrence of membranous nephropathy is rare in children, since it is unusual for the disease of membranous nephropathy to cause ESRD in children. The NAPRTCS database reports that of 7,651 pediatric patients who developed ESRD since 1987, only 36 (0.5%) had membranous nephropathy as a diagnosis. In adults, some series have reported a recurrence rate of approximately 25%, with the clinical hallmark being proteinuria; while some reports suggest that recurrence leads to graft dysfunction, other reports suggest that there is no effect on graft outcome. In the 500 transplants performed in pediatric patients at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), 2 have had membranous nephropathy and in each of those, we have observed recurrence of the biopsy picture, mild nephrotic syndrome and stability of graft function. De novo membranous nephropathy occurs more frequently and affects less than 10% of transplanted children. It usually presents later (4 months to 6 years after transplantation) than recurrent membranous nephropathy, which usually becomes apparent within the first 2 years (the mean follow-up at the time of diagnosis is 10 months in recurrent disease, compared with 22 months in de novo disease). The occurrence of de novo membranous nephropathy does not appear to affect graft outcome in the absence of rejection.