Harmonic Scalpel®
David N. Armstrong
Kurt G. Davis
Indications/Contraindications
The advantages of Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy over the more traditional use of electrocautery lie in the Harmonic Scalpel’s® improved hemostasis, resulting in an almost “bloodless” hemorrhoidectomy (1,2). In addition, postoperative pain is reduced, as a result of the reduced lateral thermal injury, compared to electrocautery.
Harmonic scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy should be reserved for patients with large external hemorrhoids, or for large, prolapsing internal hemorrhoids, that are too large for successful rubber-band ligation.
The presence of large external hemorrhoids precludes successful rubber-band ligation, for two reasons: First, the external components may become engorged, edematous, and painful after ligation because of the redirection of blood flow; second, the external components are the most obvious source of patient’s discomfort, irritation and hygiene problems, and therefore require surgical removal for patient’s satisfaction alone. Excision of the internal components is an integral and important part of standard Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy.
The standard classification of internal hemorrhoids (Grade 1: No prolapse; Grade 2: Prolapse with spontaneous reduction; Grade 3: Prolapse with manual reduction, and Grade 4: Irreducible prolapse) is not particularly useful when choosing patients for Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy, since these relate only to internal hemorrhoids. For this reason, it is often difficult to determine the contribution of internal versus external components by history alone, and the decision to perform Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy is determined by the examination of the perianal region and anal canal.
The anatomic distribution of internal and external hemorrhoids generally conform to the classic “3, 7, and 11 o’clock” (right anterior, right posterior, and left midlateral) formula. In many cases, this may not be immediately obvious, but careful intraoperative examination with a Pratt speculum usually clarifies and confirms the standard and accepted locations. Smaller components located at intervening locations are usually extensions from the main components, or simply skin tags.
Having removed the three main components, the surgeon should avoid the temptation to excise any more tissue, since such removal may result in anal stenosis. If the patient remains concerned about the residual skin tags after the procedure, these tags
can be excised under a local anesthetic in the office setting after healing has taken place. Nonetheless, such excision should only be performed on obvious protruding skin tags and only after explaining to the patient that a perfectly smooth wrinkle-free perianal region is rarely, if ever achievable.
can be excised under a local anesthetic in the office setting after healing has taken place. Nonetheless, such excision should only be performed on obvious protruding skin tags and only after explaining to the patient that a perfectly smooth wrinkle-free perianal region is rarely, if ever achievable.
The presence of a concomitant fissure is not a contraindication to Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy, as fissure debridement or internal sphincterotomy can be performed at the same time. Performing an internal sphincterotomy has never been demonstrated to reduce pain after hemorrhoidectomy, and should never be routinely performed unless in the presence of a very rigid anal stenosis.
Contraindications include any coagulopathy, use of anticoagulants, or profound immunosuppression. Apirin or other nonsteroidals are discontinued for 10 days before and 10 days after the procedure. If anticoagulants cannot be safely discontinued (e.g., mechanical heart valves), the oral anticoagulant is converted to a short-acting heparin analogue for 5 days preoperatively, and 7–10 days postoperatively. The reason for the longer postoperative hold is posthemorrhoidectomy hemorrhage that typically occurs between 5–10 days after surgery.
Patients with known anorectal Crohn’s disease should generally not undergo any form of hemorrhoidectomy. If the surgery is performed, the postoperative period is characterized by severe anorectal pain, discharge, and nonhealing incisions.
Preoperative Planning
Colonoscopy
If the patient requires colonoscopy for any of the standard indications, it can most conveniently be performed on the morning of the surgery. Colonoscopy can exclude any serious pathology within the colon and can confirm that any rectal bleeding is indeed from the hemorrhoids and not from a second unrecognized source.
Bowel Preparation
Although mechanical bowel preparation does not rise to “standard of care” prior to a Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy, it may be a sensible and safe precaution. First, the mechanical bowel preparation effectively prevents the constant oozing of stool into the surgical field during the surgery itself. Suctioning and irrigation stool out of the surgical field simply adds additional time to the procedure, and is an unpleasant inconvenience. Second, the mechanical bowel preparation postpones the patient’s first bowel movement for a few days, allowing some degree of healing to occur before this sentinel event.
Consent
The patient should be thoroughly informed of the risks of Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy. These risks include anorectal incontinence; postoperative bleeding; persistent pain/discomfort; posthemorrhoidectomy fissure or fistula.
Lab Work
Aside from preanesthetic requirements, a complete blood count usually suffices to exclude a dangerously low hemoglobin and hematocrit from prolonged severe hemorrhoidal bleeding or a dangerously low white blood count from an unrecognized immunosuppression. Both of these conditions require correction prior to an elective Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy.
Surgery
The Harmonic Scalpel® Instrument
The Harmonic Scalpel® consists of cutting shears that vibrate at 55,500 Hz, at amplitudes of 60–100 microns. The vibratory energy results in disruption of hydrogen bonds that cause denaturing of intracellular proteins. This mechanism results in shearing of the coapted tissue and creation of a sticky coagulum that further assists in hemostasis.
The principles of cutting tissue lie in two main modalities:
Pressure results from compression (coaptation) of the “active” blade onto a “pressure pad” on the opposite blade of the shears. The pressure pad focuses pressure and vibratory energy to optimize cutting of the coapted tissue.
The hemostatic coagulum is formed from denatures intracellular proteins. Because of these nonthermal modalities, the tissue is divided at a lower temperature than electrocautery, and lateral thermal injury is minimized.
The reduction in lateral thermal injury results in less postoperative pain after Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy compared to electrocautery (1). Furthermore, the hemostatic coagulum, and coapting hemostatic properties result in minimal, if any, blood loss during hemorrhoidectomy.
The Harmonic Scalpel® generator transmits energy to the hand piece at energy levels of 1–5. The lower the setting, the less the excursion of the blades and conversely, higher settings increase blade excursion.
The hand piece has two available energy settings: MIN and MAX. The MIN setting (1,2,3,4) results in more effective hemostasis, and is therefore used to divide the proximal pedicle of the internal hemorrhoid, ensuring complete hemostasis of the internal hemorrhoidal arteries. The MAX setting (defaults to level 5) results in more effective and faster cutting, and is therefore used on the tougher and less vascular external hemorrhoidal tissue.
Anesthesia
Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy is most conveniently performed in the prone-jackknife position, and under these circumstances, maintenance of the patient’s airway is the most immediate and primary concern. Harmonic Scalpel® hemorrhoidectomy may be performed under local monitored anesthesia care (MAC) (usually propofol (3)), but requires very close coordination and cooperation between the surgeon and anesthetic team. Oversedation may easily compromise the patient’s airway, especially in obese individuals.
A useful and successful compromise between local MAC anesthesia and general anesthesia with endotracheal intubation is general anesthesia using laryngeal mask anesthesia (LMA) technique (4). This technique allows the patient to be positioned awake in prone position. The LMA is inserted whilst still prone, and the table is then positioned in jackknife prior to starting the surgery (Figs. 3.1 and 3.2). After the procedure, the table is flattened, the patient rolled supine onto a stretcher, and the LMA removed from the airway. This technique avoids having to perform endotracheal intubation, avoids having to “roll” the patient from supine to prone prior to the surgery, but still maintains a safe and secure airway.