APSGN
SAGN
Time of GN onset
1–4 weeks after infection has resolved
During the course of active infection. Typically weeks to months after infection starts
Pathogen species
Group A β-hemolytic streptococcus, Group C streptococcus
Staphylococcal aureus, staphylococcal epidermidis, any other staphylococcal strain
Age of onset
Most commonly affects children between ages 5–15 years old
Most commonly affects adults with chronic illness such as diabetes mellitus or malignancy
Site of infection
β-hemolytic streptococcal pharyngitis, cellulitis, otitis media, sinusitis, or other sites
Cellulitis, chronic leg ulcers, osteomyelitis, endocarditis, dental infection, pneumonia or other sites. Upper respiratory tract would not be consistent with SAGN
Natural history
Usually resolves within several weeks but microscopic hematuria may persists for months
GN does not resolve until the infection resolves
Histology findings
Focal or diffuse proliferative immune complex glomerulonephritis with IgG and heavy C3 staining. Electron microscopy with classic subepithelial humps
Focal or diffuse proliferative immune complex glomerulonephritis in MPGN pattern with IgA and heavy C3 staining. Electron microscopy reveals mesangial and subendothelial immune complexes and may show subepithelial humps
Renal prognosis
Excellent—renal recovery occurs within 4–8 weeks of disease onset
Variable—persistent renal dysfunction common. Presence of underlying diabetic nephropathy or advanced interstitial fibrosis are predictors of poor renal outcome
Treatment
Supportive care. Steroids may be considered in severe cases with crescentic GN
Eradicate the infection. Steroids/immunosuppression is not recommended. Recurrent sepsis or death may occur if immunosuppression is used, even in those receiving antimicrobial therapy
Post-infectious GN
Post-streptococcal GN is the only proven cause of post-infectious GN. Therefore our discussion will focus on the management of post-streptococcal GN.
Post-streptococcal GN
Acute post-streptococcal GN (APSGN) occurs as an isolated case or in epidemic outbreaks. The incidence of APSGN has decreased significantly worldwide and especially in industrialized nations, but in developing nations, remains an important complication of group A streptococcus (GAS) and rarely streptococcus group C infections [3, 8]. The decrease in incidence of APSGN is attributed to earlier recognition of infection and treatment of infection with an appropriate antibiotic. In developing countries, the annual incidence of APSGN ranges from 9.5 to 28.5 new cases per 100,000 persons per year which is approximately 4 times higher than in developed countries [8]. Worldwide, APSGN still predominantly affects children, representing over 85% of reported cases [9].
APSGN is an immune complex mediated GN thought to develop after nephritogenic antigens are released into circulation during a GAS infection. The acute infection is commonly a pharyngitis or skin infection. Despite extensive study the causal nephritogenic antigens are yet to be elucidated, however the nephritis-associated plasmin receptor (NAPlr) and the streptococcal pyogenic exotoxin B (SPEB) and its zymogen precursor (zSPEB) seem most plausible [10, 11]. These nephritogenic antigens are released into circulation and deposit in glomeruli. An antibody response is mounted and these antibodies combine with the circulating antigens to form immune complexes which then deposit in the glomeruli. Additionally, the antibodies bind to the streptococcal antigens already deposited in the glomeruli leading to in situ immune complex formation. These autoantibodies are classically IgG autoantibodies and activate the alternative complement pathway as evidenced by the presence of C3 in the glomerular immune deposits in APSGN. Infiltrating leukocytes including neutrophils, T helper cells, and macrophages are responsible for the mesangial and endocapillary hypercellularity of APSGN [12].
Autoantibodies have also been detected in patients with APSGN including anti-DNA antibodies, anti-C1q antibodies, and antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (ANCA) [13, 14]. Indeed, ANCA has been found in up to 70% of APSGN that present with necrotizing and crescentic GN on biopsy [13]. The clinical relevance of these autoantibodies is unclear but they likely represent an epiphenomenon related to the autoimmunity caused by the GAS infection, and not independent processes. For more details on pathogenesis, see Chap. 7.
Clinical Manifestations and Differential Diagnosis
APSGN is characterized by an abrupt onset of hematuria. In severe cases, oliguria and renal failure with associated edema and hypertension rapidly follow. APSGN usually occurs 1–2 weeks after a pharyngeal infection and 2–4 weeks after a skin infection. APSGN typically lasts for 2–4 weeks with clinical improvement starting 1 week after presentation [9]. Subclinical disease can occur and is manifested by microscopic hematuria, low serum C3 levels, and hypertension. In children with APSGN, nephrotic range proteinuria and severe azotemia are uncommon [8]. In adults with APSGN, up to 20% may present with nephrotic range proteinuria and over 60% present with severe azotemia [8]. The hematuria associated with APSGN is characterized by gross hematuria or “tea-colored” urine (30–50%). Generalized edema (60–70%) is common, as is new onset hypertension (50–90%), and renal dysfunction (REF). Severe, rapidly progressive, necrotizing and crescentic GN is rare and may predict a poor long-term prognosis [15–17].
Laboratory findings show “nephritic” urine sediment consisting of dysmorphic red blood cells (especially acanthocytes), red blood cell casts, and mixed red and white blood cell casts. Pyuria (neutrophils) can be extensive. Still, red cells typically outnumber neutrophils. The serologic hallmark of APSGN is activation of the alternative complement pathway (low serum C3, normal serum C4). In approximately 90% of cases, serum C3 and CH50 levels are suppressed early in the disease course, and then return to normal levels at remission [18]. Serum C4 levels are usually normal or only slightly low consistent with alternative, but not classical complement pathway activation.
There are several serologic studies available to assess for recent GAS infection. The streptozyme test measures five different antibodies that target various extracellular streptococcal products and is positive in 95% of patients with a pharyngeal infection and in 80% of patients with skin infection [9, 19]. Generally, the anti-streptolysin antibody (ASO) titer is increased after a pharyngeal infection with peak titer occurring about 3 weeks after presentation [20]. However, the ASO titer is not a good indicator if pyoderma is the inciting infection [19]. Instead, anti-DNAse B antibody titers are more likely to be elevated after streptococcal skin infections [20]. These studies are particularly helpful in cases where the infection history is unclear and can help distinguish APSGN from other forms of acute nephritis, especially in adults.
The features that differentiate APSGN from other forms of acute nephritis are shown in Table 5.2. The differential diagnosis for APSGN includes autoimmune diseases that cause acute nephritis. Lupus nephritis, Henoch–Schönlein purpura (HSP), IgA nephropathy, and membranoproliferative GN (MPGN) may all present similarly to APSGN. C3 nephritis or dense deposit disease may be indistinguishable from APSGN clinically as both present with evidence of nephritis and signs of alternative complement pathway activation. In patients with MPGN, however, the clinical abnormalities persist and do not remit spontaneously. Both IgA nephropathy and HSP may present after an upper respiratory tract infection but the infection is typically synpharyngitic and occurs 1–2 days after a mucosal infection. Additionally, serum complement levels are usually normal. Lupus nephritis is an immune complex mediated GN and can present with acute nephritis similar to APSGN, however, gross hematuria is not usually seen in LN. In contrast to APSGN, the classical complement pathway is activated during lupus nephritis flare and there is no apparent relationship to a preceding infection. Finally, GN related to chronic, ongoing infections, such as staphylococcus-associated GN (discussed below) may also present with clinical features similar to APSGN, including acute nephritis with activation of the alternative complement pathway.
Table 5.2
Features that distinguish APSGN from other immune-mediated glomerular diseases
APSGN | SLE | IgAN | C3 nephritis | Staph-associated GN | ANCA vasculitis | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Clinical presentation | Acute proliferative GN that occurs 1–4 weeks after group A streptococcal infection | Lupus nephritis develops in 50% of cases of SLE. Commonly occurs alongside extra-renal manifestations of SLE | Acute GN may occur 1–3 days after developing a viral or upper respiratory tract infection | Acute GN may occur 1–3 days after viral infection | Acute proliferative GN that occurs during an active staphylococcal infection that has not yet been effectively treated | Rapidly progressive GN usually with systemic features including lung, skin and joint involvement |
Age of onset | Most commonly children 5–15 years old, rarely adults | Typically 16–40 years of age, predominantly female. Children also can be affected | Variable but usually affects 20–40 year olds | Usually develops in childhood, but adults affected as well | Most commonly occurs in adults and particularly in elderly patients with comorbidities such as diabetes mellitus | Usually affects older adults |
Histology | Immune complex mediated disease with IgG and C3, classic subepithelial “humps” | Immune complex mediated disease with “full house” pattern on immunofluorescence | IgA dominant or codominant with IgG immune complex mediated disease, mild C3 staining | No immunoglobulin, C3 only deposits in MPGN pattern, may have dense deposits | Proliferative GN with variable IgA and bright C3 staining by immunofluorescence | Pauci-immune crescentic glomerulonephritis. Few if any immune deposits identified. Severe, proliferative GN common |
Autoimmune serologies | Positive ASO, streptozyme test, ANCA titer may be positive in some cases | Positive ANA, positive anti-dsDNA, positive anti-SM antibodies | Negative | Negative | ANCA titers may be positive in some cases, otherwise negative | Positive C-ANCA or P-ANCA with either PR3 or MPO common |
Serum complement | Low C3 (90%), normal C4 | Low C3, low C4 common | Normal C3, C4 | Low C3, normal C4 | Low C3 (50%) of cases, normal C4 | Normal C3, C4 |
Microbial pathogens | Group A, B-hemolytic streptococcus | None | None | None | Staphylococcal species, especially staph aureus | None |
Treatment | Supportive care. Steroids may be considered in severe cases with crescentic GN | Immunosuppression | Supportive care. If severe, then immunosuppression | Immunosuppression? | Eradicate the infection. Steroids/immunosuppression is not recommended | Immunosuppression |
Prognosis | Excellent—renal recovery usually occurs within 4–8 weeks of disease onset | Relapsing/remitting disease prognosis is variable. 30% of patients with LN progress to ESRD | Most have a very good prognosis. Slowly progressive CKD occurs in many. ESRD risk of 20% at 20 years | Chronic GN variable prognosis, with reported risk of ESRD ranging from 16 to 76% | Acute GN with variable prognosis—persistent renal dysfunction common | Relapsing/remitting disease with guarded renal prognosis. Risk for substantial CKD high. ESRD risk 10–26% |
Differentiating APSGN from other forms of acute nephritis may be challenging, particularly in adults. Only 10–20% of pharyngitic infections are caused by GAS [21] so APSGN may be diagnosed mistakenly in patients with other forms of acute nephritis if the pharyngitis is presumed to be secondary to GAS. Also staphylococcus does not cause a pharyngitis in immunocompetent patients. An alternative diagnosis should be sought in cases where the GN does not resolve after 4–8 weeks of supportive care. However, if an alternative diagnosis is present, such as a C3 nephritis or lupus nephritis, waiting for several weeks to confirm the diagnosis will delay therapy and expose the patient to chronic kidney damage. The kidney biopsy is invaluable in such cases and maybe necessary to definitively diagnose the cause of the acute nephritis.
Role of the Kidney Biopsy in Suspected APSGN
The kidney biopsy, while the gold standard for diagnosis of most glomerular diseases, is not routinely done in patients suspected to have APSGN. The rationale is that the processes of APSGN can usually be deduced from its characteristic presentation and laboratory findings (see Table 5.2). Kidney biopsy is considered when atypical clinical features are present. For example, if the ASO or streptokinase titers are not elevated and the renal failure is severe (GFR < 30 ml/min/1.73 m2), or the nephritis is a recurrent problem then a kidney biopsy should be considered [22, 23]. The classic histologic features of APSGN include light microscopy findings of diffuse mesangial and endocapillary hypercellularity with neutrophil infiltration of the glomerular tuft, by immunofluorescence granular deposition of IgG and C3 in the capillary loops, and by electron microscopy showing the hallmark subepithelial humps. The presence of cellular crescents is uncommon but may be seen in severe cases. Since disease remission is based on resolution of clinical manifestations of nephritis, histologic remission is not typically considered but to have implications for long-term prognosis. For details on renal biopsy findings, see Chap. 1.
Treatment of APSGN
At present, there is no specific treatment for APSGN. The current approach is supportive and focuses on treating hypertension and volume overload. Acute infection has usually subsided by the time nephritis develops, thus antibiotic therapy is not usually helpful. Antibiotic therapy is, of course, recommended during the acute infection to reduce the triggers of APSGN and to prevent outbreaks. In the setting of epidemics or in high risk locations, prophylactic antibiotics should be provided to family members and other close contacts of APSGN patients [8]. This has been shown to decrease the incidence of disease in those settings [24]. As mentioned above, renal biopsy is not typically recommended since the disease is typically transient and usually goes into remission spontaneously. Clinical manifestations commonly begin to resolve 1 week after disease onset and renal function returns to baseline levels 3–4 weeks after disease onset. This is true even in cases of acute renal failure and in cases where kidney biopsy was performed and showed crescentic GN [25]. Microscopic hematuria may persist for up to 1–2 years and proteinuria may be slow to resolve [8]. Approximately 20% of patients will continue to have abnormal urine findings (hematuria or proteinuria) during long-term follow-up [26]. Overall most patients have an excellent outcome with supportive therapy alone, and disease recurrence is rare.
Supportive therapy includes symptomatic management of the acute nephritis. Sodium and fluid restriction along with diuretic therapy is considered as first line therapy to treat hypertension and volume overload. Angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors may be used to manage hypertension, however, these agents are commonly avoided due to the potential for worsening renal function acutely and causing hyperkalemia. Additionally, APSGN usually remits within several weeks so the long-term benefit of renin-angiotensin-system blockade may be negligible. Vasodilators are commonly used if additional anti-hypertensive therapy is required. Hypertensive encephalopathy may also occur and requires parenteral therapy such as intravenous nicardipine. If volume overload persists, or metabolic derangements including hyperkalemia develop, dialysis should be considered until the APSGN remits and renal function improves.
Steroid/Immunosuppressive Therapy in APSGN. In patients with rapidly progressive crescentic GN, intravenous pulses of methylprednisolone are commonly recommended to treat the acute inflammation. However, whether immunosuppression is beneficial in crescentic GN due to APSGN is unclear. The available evidence is shown in Table 5.3. As shown, most of the evidence is from small retrospective studies [27–29]. In the only available prospective study, 10 children with crescentic GN due to APSGN were stratified to receiving either immunosuppression plus anticoagulation or supportive care alone [25]. For immunosuppression, five patients were selected to receive quintuple therapy with cyclophosphamide, azathioprine, prednisone, dipyridamole, and systemic anticoagulation. The other five patients were selected to receive supportive care only. All patients had greater than 50% crescents on the initial biopsy and repeat biopsy was performed in 8 of the 10 patients. After 3 months of treatment, the clinical and histologic outcomes were similar in both groups. However, at each interval up until 3 months of follow-up, the treatment group had a more rapid improvement in creatinine clearance [25]. After 60 months of follow-up, the serum creatinine and proteinuria levels were similar between the groups. There was no correlation between severity of crescent involvement and outcome. Also, most patients in both groups attained a complete remission after 6 months of follow-up. Additionally, the level of parenchymal scarring at repeat biopsy was similar between the groups.
Table 5.3
Long-term renal prognosis in APSGN
Study location | Study year | Patient number | Patient population | Follow-up (yrs) | Albuminuria/proteinuria (%) | Persistent hematuria | Hypertension | Chronic kidney disease |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Trinidad [32] | 1982 | 534 | Children | 12–17 | 3.2 | 1.5% | 3.5% | 2% |
United States [26] | 1974 | 24 | Mixed children and adults | 10–18 | 50 | N/A | 50% | 50% |
Venezuela [8] | 2005 | 110 | Mixed children and adults | 15–18 | 7.2 | 5.4% | 13.7 | 0.9% |
Italy [34] | 1994 | 26 | Mixed children and adults | 11 | 34.6 | N/A | N/A | 7.7% |
United Kingdom [30] | 1988 | 33 | Children | 9.5–19 | 10 | 10% | 2.7% | 0% |
Brazil [63]a | 2005 | 56 | Adults | 5 | 22 | N/A | 30% | 49% |
United States (Native American Epidemic) [31] | 1964 | 61 | Native American Children | 10 | 6.6 | 8.2% | 3.3% | 0% |
Australia [35] | 1979 | 57 | Adults | 7 | 1.9 | 19% | 17% | 1.9% |
Australia [33] | 2012 | 200 | Aboriginal children | >10 | 57.6 | 13% | Similar to controls | Similar to controls |
In a more recent study, the outcomes of 27 children from New Zealand with severe APSGN were studied retrospectively. At baseline, 11 of the 27 patients had a crescentic GN. These patients were more likely to require acute dialysis at presentation [28]. Each of the patients with crescentic GN was treated with immunosuppression, either pulse methylprednisolone followed by oral prednisone alone, or in combination of cyclophosphamide. Renal outcomes were similar between the immunosuppressed group and the supportive care group. However, none of the patients who received supportive care only manifested crescentic GN at baseline [28]. This suggests that immunosuppression may have been beneficial because the group treated with immunosuppression started with worse APSGN but achieved the same outcome as those with less severe disease.
Clear conclusions cannot be made from the available evidence. Nevertheless, we suggest that immunosuppression, particularly with corticosteroids, may be helpful in severe cases of APSGN to suppress acute inflammation, limit chronic renal damage, and help facilitate a more rapid renal recovery. Figure 5.1 provides an algorithmic approach to the management of APSGN.
Fig. 5.1
Algorithmic approach to the management of acute post-streptococcal GN (APSGN). The patient presents with a history of recent infection (either pharyngitis or cellulitis) due to group A, β-hemolytic streptococcus infection. The infection resolved either with anti-microbial therapy or not. The patient now presents 1–2 weeks after the infection with signs suggestive of acute GN. Supportive care should be provided, as the GN is typically self-limited. However, if severe manifestations are present (oliguria, severe hypertension, renal failure) then treatment with corticosteroids can be considered to suppress the acute inflammation and limit chronic kidney damage. APSGN usually remits within 4–8 weeks. If the GN does not remit within this time frame, a kidney biopsy should be performed for definitive diagnosis and treatment
APSGN Prognosis and Long-Term Outcomes
The prognosis for patients with APSGN is generally excellent especially in children [30–32]. This is true even for a patient who presents with acute renal failure and the renal biopsy shows crescentic GN [25]. Determining the long-term prognosis for children with APSGN has been an area of extensive study. Earlier studies suggested that the long-term prognosis was excellent but this was based on short follow-up. Studies with longer follow-up (5–18 years) showed that approximately 20% of APSGN patients have a persistently abnormal urinalysis (hematuria, proteinuria or both) but elevated serum creatinine is rare [26]. For example, in one study, after 18 years of follow-up, 7% of children with APSGN had persistent subnephrotic range proteinuria and 5% had microscopic hematuria [26]. However, less than 1% developed end-stage renal disease. However, in another study of 200 well-characterized Australian Aboriginal children, the risk of developing persistent albuminuria after 5 years of follow-up was 3–4 times greater in those with a history of APSGN [33].
Adults with APSGN have a worse renal and overall prognosis than children [26, 34]. APSGN in adults commonly occurs in elderly patients with significant comorbidities such as alcoholism or malignancy. In these patients, azotemia, congestive heart failure, and nephrotic range proteinuria were common during the acute illness. During follow-up, 30–50% of these patients will have residual hypertension, persistently abnormal urinalysis, or chronic kidney damage [26, 35, 36]. These abnormalities are likely related to the development of glomerulosclerosis from the APSGN [26]. This was initially suggested by Baldwin and colleagues in the 1970s, after they conducted a landmark study of 118 well-characterized patients with APSGN who underwent repeat renal biopsy and were followed for at least 2 years [26]. They found that glomerulosclerosis increased from 18% at diagnosis to 56% after 5–18 years of follow-up. Proliferative lesions decreased from 93% to 11% during this same time period. Overall, 60% of patients developed at least one histologic or clinical marker of chronic damage (proteinuria, hypertension, or decreased GFR). The outcomes in children were better with only 40% having at least one manifestation of chronic damage. However, the extent to which APSGN results in end-stage renal disease is still unclear. The general experience is that APSGN rarely results in end-stage renal disease and long-term prognosis is excellent.