Techniques of Urinary Diversion

 

#RC

Period

Neo-bladder

Cont. cut

Conduit

UC TUUC

Anal

Unknown no diversion

Others

Ann Arbor

643

95–04

45.1

1.4

53.5





962

00–09

40.0

2.0

58.0



0.9


Bern

611

85–99

51.5

1.5

42.5

1.6

2.5


0.4

708

00–10

51.0

8.0

39.0

1.5

0.5


0.1

Kassel

765

94–10

30.2

6.8

60.5

0.7

2.0

0.1


Los Angeles

1,359

71–01

51.6

25.8

22.3




0.3

1,012

00–10

74.2

5.3

20.2



0.3


Lund

119

00–04

28.6

31.1

40.3





134

04–09

6.0

30.6

63.4





Mainz

335

68–80



55.0


45



593

81–90

2.0

33

41.0


15


9

982

91–00

6.0

39

41.0


12


2

1,023

01–10

15.0

24

53.0


4


4

Mansoura

3,157

80–04

39.1

3.5

34.4


23.1



Norwich

246

02–09

10.6


89.4





Swedish/Registry

158

1997

19.0

19

55.0



7


221

2003

17.0

12

70.0



1


208

2006

9.0

6

80.0



5


229

2008

15.0

4

81.0





Ulm

1,613

86–09

66.0

0.4

22.0

10.0

1.3

0.2


Vanderbilt

789

00–07

35.5

0.4

63.5


0.1


0.5

Total

15,867
 
38.0

10.4

42.2

1.2

7.5

0.1

0.8



Some conclusions from Table 18.1 are:



  • Only 3/11 institutions have experience with any type of diversion


  • Anal diversions play no role in the US, but are of value in pediatric patients and in the third world.


  • Continent cutaneous diversions play a secondary role; even former pioneering institutions use it with decreasing frequency.


  • Conduit (42.2 %) and neobladder (38 %) are the standard diversions at large centers.


  • Truly population-based data from the USA and from the Swedish Bladder Cancer Registry (S. Jahnson, Linköping, Sweden) show a neobladder rate in the range of 15 %; with increasing hospital volume the neobladder/continent diversion rate approaches 75 %, addressing the impact of hospital volume on the use of continent reconstruction.

Table 18.1 includes data of seven pioneering institutions of UD. Their average annual RC caseload is 80 (range: 27–100). The Swedish Registry includes all RCs performed annually. With a minimum of seven RC centers required for Sweden, the annual caseload would be 30. A minimum annual caseload of 25 RCs done by not more than two surgeons is the basis of a high-volume surgeon. An additional 15–20 cases performed by the next generation of high-volume surgeons under the supervision of the actual high-volume surgeons defines 40–45 RCs per year as a high-volume center [1].



18.2 General Aspects of Urinary Diversion



Urinary Diversion and Real Function


Urinary diversion into bowel segments is not inherently damaging to the kidneys. In general, renal function after diversion into continent detubularized reservoirs compares favorably with ileal conduit diversion. However, the literature is insufficient to recommend one form of diversion over another. There remains a long-term risk of renal deterioration, which is often asymptomatic, and thus close follow-up is necessary for all patients who have undergone urinary diversion in order to identify correctable causes early.

Those with renal pathology prior to surgery seem to be at greatest risk of postoperative renal deterioration. Serum creatinine is an imprecise measure of renal function. Isotopic GFR measurement will detect renal function deterioration most accurately and at an early stage. The latter, however, is not available to all patients. In these situations, follow-up with serum creatinine and ultrasound should be followed by diuresis renography if upper tract dilation is seen. Early intervention for physical obstruction often results in a sustained improvement in renal function [2].


Secondary Tumors After Urinary Diversion


Patients who have undergone conduit diversion, continent cutaneous diversion, or orthotopic bladder substitution do not seem to be at increased risk of secondary malignancy. By comparison, the risk is slightly higher after cystoplasty, albeit not increased enough to support endoscopic surveillance. However, the present knowledge regarding gastric cystoplasty is insufficient, and hence patients should be followed after such surgery. Furthermore, yearly colonoscopy is recommended in cases involving ureterosigmoidostomy, beginning 10 years after the procedure [2].


Complications


Radical cystectomy and urinary diversion are two steps of one operation. However, the literature notoriously reports on complications of radical cystectomy, ignoring that the vast majority of complications are diversion-related [3]. Surgical morbidity following urinary diversion is significant and, when strict reporting guidelines are incorporated, higher than previously published (20–57 %). Accurate reporting of postoperative complications after radical cystectomy is essential for counseling patients, combined modality treatment planning, clinical trial design, and assessment of surgical success [3].

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Mar 18, 2017 | Posted by in UROLOGY | Comments Off on Techniques of Urinary Diversion

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access