Conventional indications for endoscopic resection
High probability for en bloc resection
Tumor histology
Differentiated type adenocarcinoma
Intramucosal cancer
No lymphovascular invasion
Tumor size and morphology
≤ 20 mm elevated lesion without ulceration
≤ 10 mm if configuration is superficial depressed type (Paris classification IIc)
Extended indications for endoscopic resection
Intramucosal differentiated cancers of any size without ulceration and no lymphovascular invasion
Intramucosal differentiated cancers ≤ 30 mm with ulceration and no lymphovascular invasion
Intramucosal undifferentiated cancers ≤ 20 mm without ulceration
Differentiated cancer ≤ 3 cm with extension in the submucosa ≤ 500 μm and no lymphovascular invasion
Colorectal ESD
The risk of lymph node metastasis for early colorectal cancer correlates with the depth of invasion. Endoscopic complete resection of neoplastic lesions that are diagnosed as benign adenoma, noninvasive or minimally invasive carcinoma without vessel infiltration is considered curative regardless of the size of the tumor [19]. The indications for colorectal ESD based on the recommendations of the Korean Working Group and the Japanese Colorectal ESD Standardization Implementation Working Group are summarized in Table 2 [20, 21].
Table 2
Indications for colorectal ESD
Korean Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy ESD Study Group [20] |
Early colorectal cancers with no lymph node metastasis |
Laterally spreading tumors (LST) ≥ 20 mm |
Subepithelial lesions |
Fibrosed lesions |
Japanese Colorectal ESD Standardization Implementation Working Group [21] |
Tumor for which the use of snare EMR for en bloc resection is difficult |
Nongranular LST (especially pseudodepressed type) |
Tumor with a type VI pit pattern |
Carcinoma with shallow submucosal invasion |
Large depressed tumor |
Large elevated lesion likely containing adenocarcinoma |
Mucosal lesion with submucosal fibrosis |
Sporadic localized lesion within chronic inflammation such as ulcerative colitis |
Local residual carcinoma after EMR |
Procedural Steps of ESD
A detailed description of the actual procedural steps is beyond the scope of this review, but can be found in the recently published Endoscopic Submucosal Dissection edition of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy Clinics of North America [22−25]. In summary, the steps include:
1.
Identification and marking of the lesion with a sufficient lateral safety margin
2.
Submucosal injection and tissue elevation
3.
Circumferential or step-by-step incision (alternating with submucosal dissection) of the mucosa outside of the markings of lesion
4.
Submucosal dissection to complete “en bloc” removal of the target lesion, and subsequent retrieval
5.
Careful hemostasis and prophylactic coagulation of vessels at the resection base
6.
Preparation and orientation of the retrieved specimen for histopathological evaluation
Tools, Materials, and Techniques
Electrosurgical Knives
The contact area is one of the most important factors determining the characteristics of the specific knife. A knife with a smaller contact area usually produces a rapid and effective cut due to a higher current density with limited coagulation effect. The standard needle knife and an insulation-tipped (IT) electrosurgical knife (IT knife and IT-2 knife; KD-610 L and KD-611 L; Olympus Co., Tokyo, Japan) are mainly used for performing gastric ESDs. Since the colorectal wall is thinner than the gastric wall and the submucosal space is narrower, but with less vasculature, knives for colorectal ESD should have a short blade length and, ideally, some safety feature to prevent muscularis propria injury. The conventional resection knives and the resection knives with integrated fluid injection capability used during ESD and currently available in the West are summarized in Table 3 [26−32].
Table 3
Electrosurgical knives
Type | Description | Advantages | Manufacturer |
---|---|---|---|
Conventional resection knives | |||
Standard needle knives | Fine tip with long but regulated length | Small contact area with high cutting power | Olympus, Boston Scientific, Cook Medical |
Ceramic ball at the tip of needle knife (with triangular extension for IT-2), smaller and shorter knife (mini IT) | Decreased perforation risk, long knife makes faster cutting ability | Olympus | |
Hook knife [28] | Tip bent at a 90° and rotatable | “Fishing” and traction of submucosal fibers toward the knife before the cutting | Olympus |
Flex knife/dual knife [29] | Thin snare-like tip or fixed length tip with small rounded end | Thickened sheath end stabilize the knife and prevents deeper migration of knife | Olympus |
Triangular knife [26] | Small triangular plate at the tip | Tissue capture feasible with triangle tip | Olympus |
Resection knives with integrated fluid injection capability | |||
Hybrid knife [30] | Injection needle from the tip of the needle knife | Intermittent fluid injection then needle-knife dissection | ERBE Elektromedizin |
Flush knife [31] | Roller pump variable in rotation speed from the tip of short needle-knife (variable length) | Immediate washout of blood and debris from the endoscopic field, easy addition of submucosal cushion | Fujinon (not available in the USA) |
Ball-tip flush knife [32] | Broad catheter and short knife enlarged at the tip to a ball | Better coagulation with tip, stable movement and easy capture of tissue | Fujinon (not available in the USA) |
Submucosal Injection Agents
Submucosal injection solutions are used to lift lesions, separating mucosa from muscularis propria, but the lengthier ESD procedure (as compared to endoscopic mucosal resection (EMR)) requires prolonged elevation of the mucosa to expose the submucosal layer to facilitate submucosal dissection. Thus, the agent used for ESD must be long-lasting, safe, easy to handle, and easy to inject. In order to meet these criteria, many injection agents have been thoroughly evaluated, with some becoming commonly used. Sodium hyaluronate is now commercially available in Japan as a dedicated injection agent for ESD (MucoUp®, Johnson and Johnson Medical Co., Tokyo, Japan).
Hypertonic saline solution and dextrose are inexpensive and readily available, but both can cause tissue damage [33]. On the other hand, fibrinogen is a good submucosal cushion [34]; but, since this agent is derived from human serum, it has been criticized as a potential vehicle for viral transmission. Sodium carboxymethylcellulose [35], endoscopic lubricant jelly (Null Jelly) [36], and photocrosslinkable chitosan hydrogel may be other choices [37], but further study is necessary to verify the safety and efficacy of these alternatives. One of the most commonly used agents in Japan is Glyceol (Chugai Pharmaceutical, Tokyo), which consists of 10 % glycerol and 5 % fructose in normal saline, combined with a small amount of sodium hyaluronate [38].
Diluted epinephrine (1:100,000 to 200,000) mixed into the submucosal injection agent has been reported to reduce immediate bleeding during the endoscopic procedure [39]. However, due to the limited clinical evidence, its use is variable and may not be necessary for colorectal ESD. Indigo carmine may also be added to the injection solution to help in visualizing the area to dissect (utilizing minimum amount necessary for adequate coloring). Finally, lidocaine (1 %) has been used as a local anesthesia for rectal ESD close to the dentate line, though this may not be necessary [40].
Hoods
A transparent distal attachment (hood or cap) can be mounted on the tip of the endoscope to assist the safe and controlled use of an ESD knife. The hood pushes the resected mucosa or surrounding tissue away from the cutting plane, thus, creating countertraction and allowing better and clearer visualization of the working area. It is also useful for temporary hemostasis by tamponading the bleeding point with the tip of the hood to stop bleeding while the ESD knife is exchanged for hemostatic forceps.
The small-caliber-tip transparent (ST) hood (DH-16GR or DH-16CR; Fujifilm, Tokyo, Japan) has a tapered aperture and enables the operator to easily open up the incision to dive into the submucosal layer and accurately adjust the depth of incision that is made with the tip of the knife. Short ST hoods with a 1 mm larger opening tip than conventional ST hoods (8 mm versus 7 mm) have been developed (DH-28GR, DH-29CR, or DH-30CR; Fujifilm, Tokyo, Japan), but are not yet available in the USA [41].
Various other types of attachments can be chosen depending on the needs or situation (e.g., an attachment with holes to drain water or blood) [42]. The KUME hood (Create Medic, Yokohama, Japan) is a soft transparent distal attachment with a thin tube. It provides a jet of water via the tube attached to a water-filled syringe. Impact Shooter (Top Co., Tokyo, Japan) enables the endoscope to work like a dual-channel scope. Air Assist (Top Co., Tokyo, Japan) is a soft balloon that fits outside the endoscope, proximal to the bending area of the endoscope. It enables the endoscope to mimic a multibending scope. The EndoLifter (Olympus, Tokyo, Japan) is a distal attachment with grasping forceps that can be used to grasp the mucosa. Once the proximal area is cut and the mucosa grasped with the EndoLifter, the submucosal layer is revealed, creating easier access to the dissection plane of the submucosa; however, the proposed benefit is not consistently provided [42].
Electrosurgical Units
A high-performance ESU is indispensable for every step of the ESD procedure: marking, precutting, circumferential cutting, submucosal dissection, and hemostasis. Older ESUs only had one power setting, but the VIO series ESUs (VIO 200D, VIO 300D, ICC350, ERBE Elektromedizin, Tuebingen, Germany) have a sensor that can control the power automatically and adjust to the circumstance [20]. Each unit detects and monitors the current, power, and spark that create the cutting by controlling voltage. Therefore, the procedure can be performed in a smooth and steady manner.
There are various kinds of electric modes, each of which is used for a different purpose. The indications and characteristics of each type of current are summarized in Table 4.
Table 4
Electrosurgical unit (ESU) currents
Types | Indications | Characteristics |
---|---|---|
Endocut Q and I | Markings, mucosal incision, and submucosal dissection Hemostasis during the cut procedure | Computer-programmed mode that alternatively applying the cut and coagulation (soft or forced) current with voltage control |
Auto cut | Rarely used in ESD | Power dosing is automated (software controlled) with constant voltage |
Dry cut | Mucosal incision and submucosal dissection | Cutting mode mixed with coagulation effect |
Forced coagulation | Dissection under a strongly vascularized lesion Trimming (additional incision at the submucosal layer along the mucosal incision line) | High voltage with low duty cycle allowing effective coagulation with some cutting effect |
Swift coagulation | Submucosal dissection (sometimes used for mucosal incision) | Similar to dry cut but it has more of a coagulation effect |
Soft coagulation | Markings and bleeding control with hemostatic forceps < div class='tao-gold-member'>
Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register a > to continue
Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channelFull access? Get Clinical TreeGet Clinical Tree app for offline access |