Renal Fusion and Ectopia
ROSS M. DECTER
AMY S. BURNS
Abnormalities of renal position and fusion predispose to infection, hydronephrosis, stone disease, and, in some instances, neoplasia. Although clinical problems associated with these anomalies present infrequently in urologic practice, an understanding of the deviations from standard urologic techniques required to address them is important.
The ureteral bud branches from the wolffian duct and extends toward the metanephric blastema during the fourth and fifth weeks of gestation. The ureteral bud induces the metanephric blastema to form the functioning kidney. The exact mechanism of renal ascent is not known, but during normal development, the kidneys ascend and rotate. The renal pelvis rotates from its initial anterior position 90 degrees toward the midline until it reaches its final medial position. Migration and rotation occur simultaneously between the fourth and eighth or ninth weeks of gestation. The blood supply to the kidney is derived from successively higher levels of the aorta and its branches during ascent.
The most common anomaly of renal position is malrotation: incomplete rotation of the kidney to its final position. The renal pelvis in a malrotated kidney in general lies anterior to the parenchyma, as opposed to its normal medial location. Simple malrotation of a normally positioned kidney is often an incidental finding. The pyelocaliceal systems of malrotated kidneys are morphologically abnormal, but functionally, they usually drain without impairment. Malrotation occurs occasionally in orthotopically positioned kidneys, and it is commonly observed in ectopic kidneys.
Close approximation of the two proliferating renal blastemas prior to significant ascent is a normal embryologic finding (1). If there is any disturbance of separation of the closely approximated renal blastemas, fusion anomalies of the kidneys may develop.
The most common fusion anomaly is the horseshoe kidney. The horseshoe kidney in general ascends until the upper border of the isthmus is at the level of the inferior mesenteric artery. Horseshoe kidney occurs in 1 in 400 to 1 in 1,800 births (2). There is a male predominance for the condition (3). The fusion in horseshoe kidney almost always occurs at the lower poles; cases of upper pole fusion are recorded rarely (3). The isthmus of the horseshoe kidney lies just below the inferior mesenteric artery at the L4 vertebral level. The blood supply to these kidneys is variable (Fig. 86.1).
Crossed fused ectopia is the second most common fusion anomaly. This abnormality occurs when the developing kidney crosses from one side to the other during its ascent or when the ureteral bud from one side crosses to the contralateral side and induces abnormal development of that metanephric blastema. Crossed ectopia with fusion may occur in a variety of forms (Fig. 86.2). Although crossed ectopia occurs most frequently with fusion, the anomaly may occur without fusion (Fig. 86.3). The diagnosis should be considered in patients with a prenatal diagnosis of solitary kidney or an empty unilateral renal fossa (Fig. 86.4).
An ectopic kidney lies outside of the normal position in the renal fossa. The kidney, in simple ectopia, in general, lies in the ipsilateral retroperitoneal space at a position that is lower than normal (Fig. 86.5). In crossed ectopia, the kidney crosses the midline and is frequently fused to its contralateral mate. The autopsy incidence of renal ectopia is about 1 in 1,000 cases, and the condition often is totally asymptomatic (4). Reviews of renal ectopia show that the left kidney is affected slightly
more frequently than the right. Ectopic kidneys occur bilaterally around 10% of the time, and the most common position of the ectopic kidney is in the pelvis. Pelvic ectopia was reported in about 55% of patients in one series of ectopic kidneys, crossed fused ectopia occurred in 27%, lumbar ectopia occurred in 12%, non-crossed fused ectopia occurred in 5% of patients, and a thoracic kidney was recorded only 1% of the time (4). Rarely, a solitary pelvic kidney occurs. Obstruction or infection in the previously undiagnosed pelvic kidney can be mistaken for other intra-abdominal pathology, such as appendicitis. Furthermore, this kidney suffers the risk of injury during pelvic surgical procedures and on occasion has been reported as an unusual cause of giant hydronephrosis.
more frequently than the right. Ectopic kidneys occur bilaterally around 10% of the time, and the most common position of the ectopic kidney is in the pelvis. Pelvic ectopia was reported in about 55% of patients in one series of ectopic kidneys, crossed fused ectopia occurred in 27%, lumbar ectopia occurred in 12%, non-crossed fused ectopia occurred in 5% of patients, and a thoracic kidney was recorded only 1% of the time (4). Rarely, a solitary pelvic kidney occurs. Obstruction or infection in the previously undiagnosed pelvic kidney can be mistaken for other intra-abdominal pathology, such as appendicitis. Furthermore, this kidney suffers the risk of injury during pelvic surgical procedures and on occasion has been reported as an unusual cause of giant hydronephrosis.
FIGURE 86.1 Three common variants of blood supply in horseshoe kidney. A: Single renal arteries arising from the aorta. B: Multiple aortic arteries. C: Multiple aortic and iliac arteries. |
Ectopic kidneys are smaller than their orthotopically positioned mates (5). The blood supply to the pelvic kidney, the most common of the ectopic kidneys, is variable. The arterial
supply may arise from the distal aorta or bifurcation, the ipsilateral common iliac, or the hypogastric vessels. In general, the lower the kidney is in its pelvic location, the greater the likelihood that multiple arterial vessels will supply it (6).
supply may arise from the distal aorta or bifurcation, the ipsilateral common iliac, or the hypogastric vessels. In general, the lower the kidney is in its pelvic location, the greater the likelihood that multiple arterial vessels will supply it (6).
DIAGNOSIS
Horseshoe Kidney
Historically, 25% to 33% of patients with horseshoe kidneys who survived beyond the newborn period were asymptomatic (3). The advent of prenatal ultrasound screening makes it likely that an even larger proportion of these kidneys are asymptomatic. Patients with symptoms typically present with urinary tract infections (about 50% of the time), an abdominal mass, hematuria, or abdominal pain (approximately 10% each). Stone prevalence in horseshoe kidneys ranges from 20% to 50% (7).
The initial diagnostic evaluation in children is usually a renal ultrasound (RUS); however, sonographic detection of a horseshoe kidney can be difficult unless an isthmus is seen. Among 34 patients with known horseshoe kidney in one study, only 27 had a detectable isthmus on sonography. Other sonographic features suggesting the presence of a horseshoe kidney were low-lying renal units (78%), malrotation with anteriorly pointing pelvis (36%), bent or curved configuration of the kidney in the long axis (58%), tapering and elongation of the lower pole (60%), and a poorly defined inferior border of the kidney (84%) (8). In instances of hydronephrosis and obstruction, nuclear medicine imaging may detect presence of an isthmus not visualized on sonography (9). Because of the variability in detection of horseshoe kidney via imaging studies typically employed in children, a high index of suspicion should be maintained when performing renal surgery in children when aberrant or unexpected anatomy is encountered intraoperatively.
Symptomatic adults typically undergo computerized axial tomography (CT) where the isthmus is typically readily visible. Historically, many adults underwent intravenous pyelography (IVP) as their initial study, and the IVP features of the horseshoe kidney are typical. The renal axis is abnormal, being either vertically orientated or tilted laterally. The renal pelves tend to be located anteriorly and the ureters course ventral to the isthmus. The lower calices are oriented caudally or even medially as opposed to laterally.
Kidneys with fusion anomalies are subject to a high incidence of vesicoureteral reflux, variably reported between 20% and 50%. Voiding cystourethrography (VCUG) is therefore suggested during the evaluation of children with a horseshoe kidney.
The diagnosis of a ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) obstruction in a horseshoe kidney is straightforward when the patient’s symptoms lead to an RUS, IVP, or CT that reveals significant pyelocaliectasis. In other instances, with less severe dilation, and especially when there is coexistent stone disease, we find the diuretic renal scan a valuable adjunct in assessing the drainage of these systems and assessing whether the hydronephrosis is functionally significant.
Ectopic Kidney
Patients with a symptomatic ectopic kidney frequently present with a urinary tract infection, or the ectopic kidney is discovered in the evaluation of abdominal pain. The workup of a palpable abdominal mass and the discovery of the abnormal renal position during the evaluation of other anomalies each account for the diagnosis in about 20% of cases. Hematuria, incontinence, renal insufficiency, and nephrolithiasis are less common presenting complaints. It is important to emphasize that the majority of patients with ectopic kidneys are asymptomatic.
The evaluation in children is usually by RUS, while older patients will in general have an IVP or CT scan. The ectopic kidney can be difficult to detect on the IVP because the pyelocaliceal system often overlies the bony pelvis. Ectopic kidneys have a high incidence of associated vesicoureteral reflux, so a VCUG is a suggested part of the evaluation of these patients. Functional evaluation of the ectopically positioned kidney can be performed with a renal scan. Because the ectopic kidney is in a different plane from the orthotopic kidney, it is necessary to calculate a geometric mean from both posterior and anterior views in order to obtain an accurate differential renal function. Typically, these studies demonstrate decreased function in the ectopic kidney when compared to the normally positioned contralateral kidney. The true use, however, of a functional study is questionable, particularly if there is no evidence of reflux or hydronephrosis suggesting possible obstruction as management of these patients is not impacted. Thus, a functional study is not compulsory.
INDICATIONS FOR SURGERY
The indications for surgical intervention in the ectopic or horseshoe kidney are similar to those in a normally positioned kidney. Pyeloplasty is required in patients with symptomatic
UPJ obstruction or when the evaluation suggests that the abnormality at the UPJ may affect ultimate renal function. Symptomatic stone disease needs to be addressed using open, endoscopic, laparoscopic, or extracorporeal techniques. If the evaluation of infections in a horseshoe kidney reveals vesicoureteral reflux, operative management, either subureteral injection of Deflux or ureteral reimplantation, may be warranted if clinically indicated.
UPJ obstruction or when the evaluation suggests that the abnormality at the UPJ may affect ultimate renal function. Symptomatic stone disease needs to be addressed using open, endoscopic, laparoscopic, or extracorporeal techniques. If the evaluation of infections in a horseshoe kidney reveals vesicoureteral reflux, operative management, either subureteral injection of Deflux or ureteral reimplantation, may be warranted if clinically indicated.
ALTERNATIVE THERAPY
The alternative to surgical intervention for reflux is nonoperative management, usually consisting of observation either with or without antibiotic prophylaxis.
Surgery is the only viable option for patients with significant UPJ obstruction, sizeable stones, and tumors. Endopyelotomy has been utilized to treat UPJ obstruction in horseshoe kidneys. The initial results of endopyelotomy performed in adults by experienced surgeons are encouraging; however, formal pyeloplasty is the initial procedure for UPJ obstructions in children.