Nerve Preservation in Robotic Rectal Surgery



Fig 14.1
Front view of the lower abdomen and the pelvis illustrating the course of the superior hypogastric plexus and of the hypogastric nerves



A328092_1_En_14_Fig2_HTML.gif


Fig 14.2
Lateral view of the male pelvis illustrating the hypogastric plexus and its anatomical relationship with the seminal vesicles


These structures are situated at the sides of the rectum in the male, and at the sides of the rectum and vagina in the female. They constitute the peripheral afferent and efferent innervation of all the pelvic organs.

The superior hypogastric plexus is responsible for the sympathetic innervation of the bladder, rectum, uterus, uterine tubes, and genitals. It also carries the major part of visceral sensitive fibers originating from pelvic organs.

In men, sympathetic nerve stimulation causes seminal emission as a result of the contraction of nonstriated muscle of the genital tract and the contraction of the sphincter of the bladder neck, to prevent reflux of ejaculate into the bladder. A lesion of the superior hypogastric plexus is thus commonly associated with ejaculatory dysfunction [6].

In women, the interaction between the sympathetic and parasympathetic systems is complex and remains largely unknown; however, it has generally been presumed that a lesion to the superior hypogastric plexus can lead to impaired vaginal lubrication and dyspareunia or discomfort.

In both sexes the sympathetic system takes part in the continence mechanism. The superior hypogastric plexus inhibits the detrusor muscle of the bladder, stimulates the contraction of the smooth muscle in the bladder neck, and inhibits the parasympathetic system facilitating the storage of urine.

Erection is mainly under the control of the parasympathetic innervation that reaches the penis via the nervi erigentes. Its activity leads to the relaxation of the smooth muscles in the corpora cavernosa of the penis causing the engorgement of this erectile tissue. In the male an injury to the proerectile fibers of the parasympathetic system results in erectile dysfunction and impotence.

As with males, in females the parasympathetic activity is responsible for the vasocongestion response in this case resulting in vaginal, labial, and clitoris swelling [25]. The blood engorgement stimulates the vaginal walls to exude and parasympathetic nerves directly stimulate Bartholin’s glands to secrete mucus, providing vaginal lubrication.

An injury to the parasympathetic nerves can cause a diminished labial swelling and lubrication response in the female.

During voiding parasympathetic stimulation causes the detrusor to contract and the internal urethral sphincter to relax. When the nerve is damaged the bladder becomes noncontractile due to the detrusor hypoactivity resulting in overflow incontinence [14, 26].

Despite the advantages of a minimally invasive technique, laparoscopic rectal surgery is associated with a rate of sexual dysfunction which is similar or higher [2731] when compared with the open approach. The reason has been attributed to the technical complexities of this type of surgery such as the unstable two-dimensional view of the operative field and the poor ergonomics of the surgical tools, which render complex operation even more difficult, with a higher degree of surgeon fatigue and a steep learning curve [3234].

In the context of minimally invasive surgery , the most recent innovation is robotic surgery. The first robotic colorectal surgery was performed in 2002, and in the following years many authors have demonstrated that robotic TME is an oncologically safe and feasible procedure that facilitates mesorectal excision [35, 36]. The magnified vision, the superior dexterity, and precision of movements of the robotic arms allow the surgeon a better view and greater ergonomic comfort for the dissection of the small anatomical structures [3638].

The improved view of the small anatomical pelvic structures together with the more precise and accurate dissection offered by the robotic system during mesorectal resection can help the surgeon to recognize the inferior hypogastric plexus and to reduce the risk of collateral damage to the pelvic autonomic nerves. As a result of these advantages, robotic nerve-sparing TME allows for better preservation of urinary and sexual function when compared with the literature data on both open and laparoscopic surgery [39].



Key Points for Nerve-Sparing Surgery and Surgical-Related Lesions


Four main zones have been identified as being at high risk for nerve injury during total mesorectal excision [4042]:


  1. 1.


    Ligation of the inferior mesenteric artery

     

  2. 2.


    Posterior dissection of the mesorectum

     

  3. 3.


    Lateral dissection of the mesorectum

     

  4. 4.


    Anterior isolation of the rectum

     

Moreover, damage to the pelvic nerves may occur during intersphincteric resection or abdominoperineal resection.

Ligation of the inferior mesenteric artery : ligation or stapling at the origin of the inferior mesenteric artery has the objective of complete removal of the regional lymph nodes. To avoid injury to the superior hypogastric plexus, it is important to identify the nervous fibers that run along the aorta and gently displace them before dividing the IMA (Fig. 14.3).

A328092_1_En_14_Fig3_HTML.jpg


Fig 14.3
Isolation of the IMA . The small neurons lying in front of the aorta are identified and respected

Sharp dissection is then continued down in order to identify the virtual space between the fascia propria of the mesorectum and the presacral parietal fascia. If the posterior plane of dissection of the mesorectum is correct, then it should be easy to identify the hypogastric nerves. If the dissection is carried below the parietal fascia an injury to the hypogastric nerves can occur. Conversely, if the dissection plane is too superficial the mesorectal fascia will be infracted. This can affect the quality of the specimen and is directly associated with the risk of local recurrence, as demonstrated by Quirke and Dixon [43].

Particular attention should be paid to the lateral dissection of the mesorectum. At this level the hypogastric nerves run adherent to the fascia propria and can be easily injured. A typical mistake occurs when the dissection is not performed in a “posterior to anterior” fashion but the mesorectum is freed posteriorly, anteriorly, and then tractioned to one side to complete the isolation. In this case the nerve is usually pulled medially and transected together with the tissue that some authors consider to represent the lateral ligament of the rectum. When the dissection is carried out from the posterior to the lateral aspect of the mesorectum, it is almost always possible to identify the hypogastric nerves and isolate them sharply without the need for clamping or excessive electrocoagulation close to the neural structures. This technique is also useful to reduce prolonged and extensive traction of the nerves.

The dissection then proceeds toward the anterior isolation of the rectum where this organ is in close contact with the nerves that originate from the inferior hypogastric plexus and carry both sympathetic and parasympathetic fibers to the bladder and sexual organs via the neurovascular bundles. They are located lateral to Denonvillier’s fascia in close proximity to the seminal vesicles. Every effort should be made to preserve both bundles when not involved by the tumor. If both nerves are sectioned, the rate of impotence will be 100 % [44]. However, potency rates will decrease substantially even when only one of the neurovascular bundles is left intact [45, 46].

In the case of involvement of the anterior wall of the rectum by the tumor, Denonvillier’s fascia should then be removed, as described by Heald, in order to reduce the risk of a positive circumferential margin. However, particular attention should be paid when dissecting the lateral margins of the rectoprostatic fascia and the rectovaginal septum that are in close relationship with the fibers of the inferior hypogastric plexus for the genitalia.

In most cases, when there is no anterior extrafascial extension of cancer and therefore no risk of neurovascular bundle involvement, it is possible to maintain the dissection plane closer to the mesorectal fascia and away from the seminal vesicles. When the tumor is located in the posterior rectal wall Denonviller’s fascia can be preserved [15, 47].

Different mechanisms of nerve lesions are considered to lie at the basis of genitourinary dysfunction in intersphincteric and abdominoperineal resection. A more extensive pelvic dissection, with an increased risk of pelvic nerve injury is common for both types of operation: different studies have shown a direct correlation between the distance of the tumor from the anal verge and the postoperative dysfunction rates [24, 48, 49]. There is nonetheless a general consensus that abdominoperineal resection has the worse functional outcomes [7, 18, 5052]. The distortion of pelvic floor anatomy may not only lead to a loss of support for the urethra and the bladder but may also alter the mechanism of contraction of the bulbocavernous muscle which is involved in erection function and ejaculation [53, 54].


Instrument Use and Surgical Techniques


Various techniques and approaches have been developed for robotic total mesorectal excision [5561]. However, most of the principles and points to be considered for the preservation of the autonomic nerves during surgical dissection are similar regardless of the technique applied.

Thermal, mechanical, and vascular damage are the principal causes of nerve injury and consequent urinary and sexual dysfunction. The extensive use of electrocoagulation should be avoided in particular on the lateral plane of dissection due to the anatomical proximity between the mesorectal fascia and the hypogastric plexus, and on the anterolateral plane, near the vesicles, where the neurovascular bundle is in close contact with the rectum. When needed, surgical clips should be applied for hemostasis. Excessive traction has been identified as a cause of neuropraxia that can lead to a temporary or unrecoverable blockage of nerve conduction depending on the grade and the duration of the traction [62, 63]. Delicate handling of the neurovascular tissue is also important to preserve the vasa nervorum and to prevent ischemic damage to the nerves. Traction-free techniques and gentle handling can be difficult during the learning curve phase in robotic surgery due to the absence of haptic feedback, when the surgeon has not yet learned to compensate this lack of sensation with visual integration. This issue is also important for the assistant surgeon whose main function is, for the most part, to provide countertraction during the intervention. Trainees should be instructed to avoid excessive tension during tissue manipulation [64].

The identification of all the components of the hypogastric plexus is of paramount importance to reduce the incidence of genitourinary dysfunction and injury can occur if the autonomic nerves cannot be kept under visual control during the dissection [6568]. For this reason bleeding control is important because excessive blood in the operating field can make it very difficult to identify the nerves [13, 69]. The three-dimensional magnified High Definition view coupled with a stable camera platform offered by the da Vinci System helps in recognizing the smaller anatomical structures of the inferior hypogastric plexus and the anatomical planes, in particular during the anterior isolation of the mesorectum, which represents the most dangerous phase, where there is a high risk of lesion to the neurovascular bundle. The significant reduction of intraoperative blood loss reported may also contribute to the identification of the autonomic nerves [18, 70]. Moreover, the stability and superior movements with the increased flexibility and precision of robotic arms permit a more accurate dissection, especially in narrow spaces such as the conically shaped male pelvis and reduce the risk of collateral damage to surrounding tissues [56]. Quality of dissection and preservation of sexual and urinary function are, in fact, directly related [71] (Fig. 14.4). As a mnemonic for the trainee surgeons starting their surgical activity at the console we explain that robotic nerve sparing total mesorectal excision should be CLEAN: Circumferential from posterior to anterior as described by Heald; with Light tension on the structures; Electrocoagulation-free; Atraumatic to preserve the vasa nervorum and Nerve-guided: following the autonomic nerves (Table 14.1).

A328092_1_En_14_Fig4_HTML.jpg


Fig 14.4
Robotic TME specimen showing shiny intact mesorectal surface



Table 14.1
The CLEAN acronym: a mnemonic aid for performing a correct nerve-sparing technique





















C

Circumferential: the isolation of the mesorectum should be circumferential, from posterior to anterior following the principles described by Heald

L

Light: as the tension that should be applied on the anatomical structures

E

Electrocoagulation free

A

Atraumatic: to preserve the nerves and the vasa nervorum

N

Nerve guided: during TME the autonomic nerves should be identified and followed


Conclusions


The primary objective of rectal cancer surgery is to obtain oncologic radicality to thereby minimize local recurrence. However, quality of life (QoL) is an important variable of oncological excellence and the ideal approach for the prevention of genitourinary complications of rectal cancer treatment is multidisciplinary with a close collaboration between the different specialists.

Since the inception of techniques aiming at the preservation of the autonomic nervous system during TME, the incidence of sexual and urinary dysfunctions has decreased.

The da Vinci surgical system is a powerful tool that offers more precision, more dexterity, and a better view of the operating field during total mesorectal excision. Nevertheless, we should bear in mind that the robot only enhances the skills and the capabilities of the surgeon. To achieve good results it is essential to have a sound knowledge of pelvic neuroanatomy and of the principles of nerve-sparing total mesorectal excision.


References



1.

Weir HK, Thun MJ, Hankey BF, et al. Annual report to the nation on the status of cancer, 1975-2000, featuring the uses of surveillance data for cancer prevention and control. J Natl Cancer Inst. 2003;95:1276–99.CrossRefPubMed


2.

Heald RJ, Husband EM, Ryall RD. The mesorectum in rectal cancer surgery—the clue to pelvic recurrence? Br J Surg. 1982;69:613–6.CrossRefPubMed

Jul 11, 2017 | Posted by in UROLOGY | Comments Off on Nerve Preservation in Robotic Rectal Surgery

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access