History of Transurethral Resection and Fulguration of Bladder Tumors


Year

Individual

Innovation

1806

P. Bozzini

Lichtleiter

1853

A. J. Desormeaux

First endoscopic operation—extraction of urethral papilloma

1873

G. Trouve

Polyscope—electroendoscopy

1876

D. Rutenberg

Blasenspiegel—air cystoscopy

1877

M. Nitze

Cystoscope

1878

T. Edison

Incandescent light bulb

1881

J. Grunfeld

Polypenkneipe—first removal of bladder papilloma

1894

M. Nitze

Operating cystoscope

1908

R. Wappler

Monopolar high-frequency (Oudin) current—the resonator

1910

E. Beer

Fulguration of bladder tumors

1911

E. Frank

Bipolar electrocoagulation of bladder tumors

1926

M. Stern

First resectoscope

1928

W. T. Bovie

Separate current for coagulation and cutting

1931

J. McCarthy

Improved Stern resectoscope for bladder tumors

1931

T. Davis

Combined cutting current with diathermy, dual-action foot switch

1938

R. Nesbit

One-handed resectoscope

1959

H. Hopkins

Rod-lens fiberoptic system. Led to flexible cystoscopy

1970

W.S Boyle and G. S. Smith

Charge-coupled-device (CCD)—led to digital endoscopy and video-assisted TURB



In the mid-nineteenth century, Desormeaux introduced his endoscope, and cystoscopy became established as a practical, although difficult, means of clinical investigation. He designed his instrument around a paraffin flamed that burned more brightly by the addition of turpentine. In 1853, Desormeaux was able to perform the first true endoscopic operation when he extracted a papilloma through the urethra using his urethroscope [3]. Trouve made a critical contribution to cystoscopy in 1873 when he moved the light source (a glowing hot platinum wire) to the inner tip of his “Polyscope.” In 1876, Rutenberg, attempting to improve vision within the female bladder, designed his “Blasenspiegel” through which he was the first to observe the larger surfaces of the bladder. Later, the dermatologist Grunfeld improved endoscopic surgery in the urethra and bladder. He developed a urethroscope , as well as endoscopic loop threaders, scissors, forceps, and knives, and was the first to operate in the bladder under direct control of the eye when he removed a bladder papilloma through his urethroscope in 1881. In 1885, Grunfeld developed the “Polypenkneipe ,” the first cystoscope specifically designed to remove tumors from the urethra and bladder [4].



Max Nitze and the Operating Cystoscope


Maximilian Nitze introduced the first direct-vision cystoscope in 1877, which markedly improved vision inside the bladder but offered limited operating capability [5]. Never satisfied, from 1891 to 1894, Nitze designed and constructed the first practical operating cystoscope (Fig. 6.1). He became the first to coagulate a bladder polyp visualized with Edison’s new light bulb and using cold and hot wire loops for galvanocautery. He initiated systematic cystoscopic treatment of bladder tumors and reported removal of tumors from 150 cases with only 1 death and 20 recurrences. Using curette, cutting forceps, cautery, and wire loop, he was able to remove many papillary tumors cleanly [6]. Others followed his lead, and in 1905, Weinrich reported treating 101 cases of bladder tumors by the Nitze method with 71% recoveries without a recurrence. The procedure was mostly excision of pedunculated tumors with a portion of mucosa or else twisting off the pedicle at its base. For most European and American urologists, however, the Nitze cystoscope was cumbersome to manipulate, and galvanic cautery using the wire loop proved to be an unreliable means of tissue destruction. With advent of diathermy in the United States, surgery of bladder tumors using Nitze’s operating cystoscope was practically abandoned.

A339752_1_En_6_Fig1_HTML.gif


Fig. 6.1
Operating cystoscope, developed by M. Nitze in 1891–1894


Cystofulguration


Nagelschmidt and Doyen in the United States were the first to advocate use of electrically induced heat to treat cancerous growths. Nagelschmidt devised an adequate apparatus for this purpose and is credited with originating the term diathermy. But it was Edwin Beer of New York who really founded electrosurgery of the bladder.

In 1908, Beer, convinced that Nitze’s earlier transurethral treatment of bladder tumors was superior to open surgery, conceived the idea of using high-frequency electric current through a catheterizing-cystoscope to coagulate bladder tumors. He used a two-channel Nitze cystoscope (one channel for a 6F copper electrode and the other for irrigation of the bladder) and a monopolar (Oudin) current derived from a resonator made by the American cystoscope maker, Reinhold Wappler. Direct current was applied at various points to papillary growths for 15–30 s at a time, while the bladder was distended with sterile water. Beer treated two women and saw no spark when the full current was thrown on without resistance. Tumor tissue was dessicated at cautery points even under water, and patients experienced no more discomfort than during ordinary cystoscopy. Beer concluded that coagulation was simpler than loop treatment, and in 1910, he reported his successful cases in a landmark article, claiming fulguration to be “proven effective in the cure of bladder papilloma” [7].

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jan 29, 2018 | Posted by in UROLOGY | Comments Off on History of Transurethral Resection and Fulguration of Bladder Tumors

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access