Advancing age
Diabetes
Obesity
Neurological disorders
Female gender
Urinary incontinence
Caucasian race
Chronic diarrhea
Multiple vaginal births
Constipation
Sphincter tear with delivery
Pelvic organ prolapse
Surgical procedures (colectomy, sphincterotomy)
Gastrointestinal disorders (Crohn’s disease, ulcerative colitis, irritable bowel disease)
The etiology of fecal incontinence is multifactorial and can be broadly divided into traumatic events, neurogenic causes congenital malformations, intestinal causes and others. A more comprehensive list of potential causes of fecal incontinence is listed in Table 18.2 [14–16]. Traumatic damage to the nerves, muscles, and/or blood supply of the rectum and continence mechanism from childbirth, forceps injury, accidental trauma, surgery or radiation may lead to fecal incontinence. Obstetrical injury is the most common cause of fecal incontinence in women and may be the result of injury to nerves and/or muscle that may occur during vaginal delivery, from an episiotomy, a third- or fourth-degree laceration, or an occult injury to the sphincteric complex. This may directly lead to fecal incontinence after delivery or may be a contributing factor to fecal incontinence later in life. Studies have shown that sphincteric defects and/or incompetence may be persistent after a perineal repair despite what was thought to be an adequate repair. Additionally, prolonged compression of the pudendal nerve during delivery may result in permanent nerve injury, which can contribute to both fecal and urinary incontinence [15, 16]. Pelvic radiation, which may compromise rectal compliance through tissue damage and fibrosis, is another form of trauma, leading to fecal incontinence. Similar to bladder physiology, rectal compliance refers to the ability of the rectum to distend while intraluminal pressures remain low. A decrease in rectal compliance can lead to urgency and fecal incontinence [17]. Similarly, a loss of rectal capacity, measured by the amount of material that can be successfully and comfortably stored in the rectum, can lead to fecal incontinence by allowing the rectum to be overwhelmed by severe diarrhea or fecal impaction. The etiology of a patient’s fecal incontinence should be determined in order to discern if the incontinence is reversible or treatable.
Table 18.2
Potential causes of fecal incontinence
Traumatic: | Intestinal: |
Obstetric | Colitis |
Surgical | Colorectal tumors |
Radiation | Rectal prolapse |
Neurogenic: | Decreased compliance or capacity |
Multiple sclerosis | Fecal impaction |
CVA | Diarrhea |
Diabetic neuropathy | Others: |
Dementia | Aging |
Neoplasm | Laxative abuse |
Congenital: | Idiopathic |
Spinal cord malformation | |
Anorectal malformation |
Evaluation
History and Physical
The evaluation of patients with fecal incontinence should begin with a thorough history and physical examination. Specifically, patients should be queried regarding the duration, frequency and severity of symptoms; type of incontinence (gas, liquid, and/or stool); daily bowel habits, including constipation and diarrhea; obstetrical history; new medications or diet changes and past medical and surgical history. Additionally, the patient should be instructed to fill out a bowel diary so that the patient’s dietary habits, number of incontinence episodes per day and quality of the incontinence (measured via the Bristol scale) can be objectively evaluated by the clinician. Incontinence questionnaires such as the Fecal Incontinence Severity Index, Fecal Incontinence Quality of Life Scale, and the Cleveland Clinic Incontinence Score can be employed to assess severity of fecal incontinence and quality of life [10]. These questionnaires can also be useful in determining the degree of improvement in symptoms after treatment.
During the physical exam, a thorough evaluation of the perineum, anus, and vagina should be performed. A digital rectal exam should include evaluation of the rectal tone and the ability of the patient to contract the external anal sphincter as well as the presence of hard stool, internal hemorrhoids, blood and masses in the rectum. External evaluation of the perineum and perianal skin should assess for fecal soiling, scarring, erythema, external hemorrhoids, rectal mucosal prolapse, anal fistulas, and the classic “dovetail” sign suggesting a defect in the external anal sphincter (Fig. 18.1). Additionally, the clitoral-anal and bulbocavernosus reflexes may be tested in order to grossly assess the pudendal nerve. Vaginal examination can aid in determining the presence of an enterocele, rectocele, or rectovaginal fistula.
Fig. 18.1
Dovetail sign
Diagnostic Studies
Diagnostic studies may be performed to determine the etiology or possible treatment options for patients with fecal incontinence. Unfortunately, testing is not standardized and may produce normal results despite the presence of fecal incontinence. Therefore, there is some debate over the necessity and use of these tests. However, they may be useful if additional information is required, to determine the most effective treatment options so that the best possible outcomes can be obtained.
Anorectal physiology testing includes anal manometry and neurophysiologic studies such as the pudendal nerve terminal motor latency testing and needle electromyography (EMG) of the external anal sphincter. Anal manometry involves the use of transducer catheters and balloons to measure the resting and squeeze pressures of the external and internal anal sphincters and the rectum. Additionally, during testing an inflated balloon may be employed to determine rectal capacity, sensation and the presence of the rectoanal inhibitory reflex (RAIR). Pudendal nerve latency testing is performed by stimulating the pudendal nerve and measuring the amount of time required for the stimulus to induce a contraction of the external anal sphincter. A normal delay is approximately 2.0 ms, and a prolongation may suggest a neuropraxic injury. This test is operator dependent, does not correlate well with patient symptoms and is best used when interpreted in conjunction with needle EMG of the external anal sphincter. Needle EMG of the external anal sphincter may be employed to determine the innervation status of the external anal sphincter but can be particularly uncomfortable for the patient. Surface EMG electrodes may be substituted but are not as precise and give more of a global picture of muscle function. A colonoscopy is a generally recommended procedure for colon cancer screening after the age of 50 years, but it may also be employed to investigate fecal incontinence or changes in bowel symptoms as it may reveal the presence of diverticulitis, rectal masses, or a mucosal abnormality.
Imaging studies such as defecography, endoanal ultrasound and MRI may also provide additional diagnostic information. Defecography is a fluoroscopic procedure that involves inserting barium paste into the rectum and obtaining images as the patient contracts the pelvic floor, strains with attempt at maintaining continence, and attempts to defecate. This test may aid in the diagnosis of obstructed defecation, rectoceles, enteroceles and rectal prolapse. Endoanal ultrasound can assess the integrity of the external and internal anal sphincter and may be useful in operative planning if an anatomic defect is discovered. A 360° endoanal transducer is available that can accurately assess the integrity, thickness and length of the internal and external anal sphincters (Fig. 18.2). Additionally, MRI may assess atrophy of the external anal sphincter and levator ani muscles including the puborectalis [18–21].
Fig. 18.2
(a) Internal and external anal sphincter defects. (b) 360° endoanal US with internal and external sphincter intact. (c) 360° endoanal US with internal and external sphincter defects
Treatment
Nonsurgical
Conservative therapy such as dietary modification, pharmacotherapy and pelvic floor therapy are the first line in treatment of fecal incontinence. Patients should be counseled regarding the importance of dietary modification as they can have a significant impact on bowel function, stool consistency and bowel motility. Right amount of fiber in the diet helps with diarrhea and constipation. Fruits, vegetables, whole grains, breads and beans are good source of fibers. Increasing dietary fiber with bulking agents, such as calcium polycarbophil or psyllium, has been noted to have beneficial effects on colonic function as well as cholesterol levels and glucose metabolism. Ironically, increasing dietary fiber can help treat both diarrhea and constipation. In the setting of diarrhea, fiber improves stool consistency, decreases stool frequency and reduces fecal water content, while in the context of constipation, fiber increases stool frequency and fecal weight, without leading to diarrhea.
Another important dietary consideration to discuss with patients is the high rate of lactase deficiency in the general population. Lactose, which is digested by lactase found in the bowel, is a common sugar found in milk and dairy products. Adhering to a dairy-free diet for 2 weeks may have a significant impact on bowel symptoms. Furthermore, the effect of caffeine, a stimulant that may increase urgency in susceptible patients, should be reviewed with the patient. Finally, ingestion of probiotics does appear to have a beneficial effect in patients with irritable bowel disease but there are no reported studies on the effectiveness of probiotics in fecal incontinence.
Due to the variety of underlying causes and contributing factors, there is no one global pharmacological treatment for fecal incontinence. Therefore, treatment with medications should be directed towards controlling symptoms of constipation or diarrhea. Loperamide, diphenoxylate hydrochloride, codeine phosphate, anticholinergics and atropine sulfate are all medications that may be tried to help control symptoms of diarrhea. Loperamide is a synthetic agent that binds opioid receptors in the bowel, inhibits small and large bowel peristalsis and has the added benefit of increasing resting anal sphincter tone [22, 23]. Similarly diphenoxylate hydrochloride also binds to opioid receptors in the bowel, but due to this medication’s ability to cross the blood-brain barrier, it is a controlled substance in the United States. However, diphenoxylate hydrochloride has minimal potential for physical dependence. For medical treatment of constipation, laxatives and enemas may be employed along with dietary modifications to help the patient from developing impacted stool in the rectum, which may lead to fecal incontinence from loose seepage around the impacted stool. If constipation persists, manual disimpaction is an option to help remove impacted stool from the rectum.
Pelvic floor physical therapy aimed at improving the strength of the levator ani muscle group and the external anal sphincter is another treatment option. Biofeedback, in the form of manual pressure or EMG feedback, rectal distension balloons to train threshold sensation and coordination training are a few tools that pelvic floor physical therapists employ in pelvic floor muscle training. A Cochrane review of recent published trials concluded that currently there is insufficient evidence to definitively define the role of physical therapy and biofeedback in the treatment of fecal incontinence; however, larger studies are needed for future assessment [24].
Surgical
If conservative treatment is not successful, there are several surgical options available, based on the etiology [25].
Sphincteroplasty
When there is a defect in the external or internal anal sphincter, a sphincteroplasty may be performed in order to re-approximate the two ends of the sphincter. The repair can be done end to end, which is the most common postpartum method or overlapping, the most common delayed method. There is limited data available supporting one method compared to the other, but a Cochrane review in 2006 reviewed three randomized controlled trials and found that an overlapping sphincteroplasty performed promptly after an obstetrical trauma may lower the risk of fecal urgency and improve anal incontinence symptoms [26]. However, the rates of anal incontinence and dyspareunia were similar at 12 months post-surgery. Another randomized control trial looked at delayed repair with overlapping versus end-to-end methods, and no difference was seen in the failure rates (17–25 %) or in the complication rates [27]. A list of short- and long-term studies reviewing surgical outcomes after sphincteroplasty may be seen in Tables 18.3 and 18.4.
Table 18.3
Results for sphincteroplasty with mean follow-up of < 5 year duration