Failure to Thrive




(1)
Department of Child Health, University of Missouri, Columbia, MO, USA

 





Chapter Outline



  • Definitions: Failure to Thrive/failure to grow


  • Philosophic considerations: “organic vs. psychogenic”—The biomedical dichotomy


  • Misconceptions about Failure to Thrive:



    • That it is necessarily is caused by undernutrition


    • That it is necessarily caused by neglect


    • That it is necessarily caused by poverty


  • Conditions that may be mistaken for clinically significant growth failure:



    • Small for gestational age


    • Constitutional growth lag


    • Genetic small stature


  • What is required for thriving?



    • Emotional aspects


    • Nutritional aspects


  • Specific Failure to Thrive syndromes



    • Nervous vomiting


    • Infant Rumination Syndrome


    • Deprivation dwarfism


  • Recognizing Failure to Thrive in children with undifferentiated growth failure: “The four Categories” of Failure to Thrive



    • Type 1: growth lag with no symptoms


    • Type 2: growth lag with misleading symptoms


    • Type 3: growth lag accompanied by abuse or neglect


    • Type 4: Failure to Thrive superimposed in children with organic disease


  • Summary of management concepts


Definitions: Failure to Grow/Failure to Thrive


Failure to Thrive (FTT) is usually defined as failure to grow due to any cause. In this chapter, however, FTT is defined as a special kind of failure to grow, namely, growth failure caused by aberrant nurturing [1]. Although organic diseases, such as kidney failure, cystic fibrosis or congenital heart disease, may impair growth, a large proportion of infants and children who present with growth failure have no underlying organic disease. Instead, they fail to grow because of dysfunction within their parent–child relationships, and it is this kind of growth failure to which the term FTT is specifically applied.


Philosophical Considerations


Conventional, biomedical practice dichotomizes illness as either organic or psychogenic, the former being materialistic and the province of medicine, the latter being insubstantial or “mental” and the province of the mental health professions. However, advances in the neurosciences have increasingly shown the unity of mind-brain-body. Sustained emotional stress, for example, has been shown to cause alterations in the anatomy and function of the brain and other organs, many of which affect behavior and influence growth and development [2].

The biomedical approach to diagnosis is dichotomized and biased in favor of organic disease. The process is sequential: first, rule-out all plausible organic causes of growth failure and only then consider psychosocial factors. Even when psychosocial pathology is evident on first encounter, the clinician adhering to the biomedical model may avoid this aspect of growth failure out of concern that an organic disease might be missed. Unfortunately, medical diagnostic procedures are not necessarily benign, especially in infants and children. They often involve pain, anguish, exposure to ionizing radiation and other adversities. The task of the clinician is to identify the causes of growth failure in a manner that not only diagnoses them correctly, but does so in a manner that is least stressful or damaging to the patient.

The biopsychosocial approach, as described below, avoids both organic and psychogenic biases and, instead, approaches both aspects of failure to grow simultaneously, pursuing a course that is flexible, influenced by the most likely elements as they emerge during the evaluation. This lessens the likelihood of what John Apley called “wantonness of inquiry” during which “the doctor has the notion that if he excavates long enough and deep enough the answer [i.e., the organic diagnosis] will come up” [3].

The central nervous system modulates the activity of the stomach. Emotional stress has long been known to cause disordered gastrointestinal motility [4] (as exemplified by the abnormal X-ray findings of narrowing of the outflow passage of the stomach in some infants with “nervous vomiting”) [5, 6]. The functional nature of such vomiting, and any other presentation of FTT, can be positively differentiated from organic disease by the infant’s response to a procedure referred to as “a therapeutic trial of comfort,” (analogous to the rest period that relieves a muscle cramp). This therapeutic/diagnostic procedure is described below.

This is not to say that functional and organic disorders are mutually exclusive or that functional disorders cannot have serious or even fatal organic complications. However, it would be a mistake to focus on the disease caused by a functional disorder without attending to the underlying causes of that disorder. This error is exemplified by a recommendation for fundoplication surgery to prevent vomiting in an infant with FTT due to unrecognized Infant Rumination Syndrome [7].


Some Misconceptions About FTT


Failure to thrive (FTT) in infants and children is characterized by lags in somatic growth often accompanied by delays in cognitive, motor, and emotional development. The complexity of FTT has led to conceptual oversimplifications.

One oversimplification is the notion that FTT is simply equivalent to undernutrition and that the problem can be cured by getting the child to eat more. Although poor nutrition may be the most salient feature in children with FTT, nutritional deficits are merely symptomatic of their causes. Unless poor nutrition is the result of organic disease or famine, the causes of inadequate food intake in FTT almost always involve problems in the relationship between child and its principle caregiver. If the nature and causes of the dysfunctional relationship are not brought to light and addressed, clinical management of FTT is not likely to achieve optimal success.

Another misconception is that failure to thrive signifies neglect. Although neglect may be the immediate cause of FTT in some cases, FTT can also occur in children of attentive, devoted parents.

Many published series of children with FTT were reported from large city hospitals serving medically indigent populations. As a result, the impression may be gained that FTT is a manifestation of poverty. However, FTT also occurs in middle- and upper-class families.


Conditions that may be Mistaken for Clinically Significant Growth Failure


Diagnosing growth failure on the basis of one-time measurements can be very misleading. It is helpful to plot a patient’s growth before eliciting the history and then, during history-taking, marking on the abscissa the ages of the child at which significant events occurred. The morphology of the curve may make cause-and-effect relationships stand out. A growth curve is far superior to a single set of measurements for evaluation of growth.

Among the many growth patterns that may be mistaken for FTT, three warrant special mention: children who were born small for gestational age [8], children with constitutional growth delay [9], and children with genetic short stature.

Infants born with Intra-uterine Growth Retardation have sustained a pathological insult that caused them to fall short of their expected potential for growth [8]. They may be proportionate in length, weight and head circumference, or their weight may be disproportionately less than their length and head circumference. Those whose measurements are abnormally small but in-proportion are likely to have sustained an insult early in gestation, such as infection, chromosomal abnormalities or exposure to teratogens; they generally have a poorer prognosis for catch-up growth. Those whose weights are disproportionately small for their lengths and head sizes are likely to have sustained an insult later in gestation (e.g., placental insufficiency, maternal malnutrition or hypertension) and have a generally better prognosis for catch-up growth [9].

Constitutional growth delay is a normal variant seen in some healthy infants. Their growth progresses normally until sometime between 4 and 12 months when height and weight gains slow causing down-shifts of their curves to lower channels. Slow or arrested growth persists for several months followed by spontaneous resumption of normal growth rates by 2–3 years of age, usually along channels lower than those followed prior to the period of delayed growth [9].

Children with genetic short stature are healthy and typically grow at normal rates, parallel to, but at or below the 5th or 3rd percentile channels. There is usually a family history of small stature.


What is required for thriving? The Pathogenesis of Failure to Thrive: The Emotional and Nutritional Aspects of Nurturing—How Aberrant Nurturing Can Cause Growth Failure



Emotional Aspects


Nurturing is the process by which infants survive, grow and develop. It has emotional, cognitive and nutritional aspects. It takes place within a dyadic relationship made up of the infant and its principal caregiver [10].

In a well-functioning dyad, mother and infant interact in a reciprocal manner so that the infant’s behavior and the caregiver’s behavior are mutually regulatory [11]. Actions, responses, and reactions occur during which the infant’s cues are appreciated by the mother who then reacts in a timely, sensitive, contingent manner [12]. These interactions, over time, foster the infant’s sense of existing as an individual, physically and cognitively separate from his or her mother, and able to express a need with the expectation that it will be correctly interpreted and responded to. In order for a dyadic relationship to function, the mother must have first “fallen in love” with her infant and “claim” her baby as her own, physically and emotionally [13]. “Claiming” may occur immediately in the delivery room the moment the baby is put to her breast, it may occur sometime later, or may not sufficiently take place at all. Without it, however, there may be insufficient motivation for devoted caring and the capacity for feeling pleasure and pride in her baby and in her achievements as a mother, all of which foster effective nurturing [14].

The infant’s capacity to engage in dyadic interaction depends upon its ability to manage transitions of state, including those required for feeding and eating. The infant in utero has little experience with changes in state. Feeding is continuous; there is no experience of hunger or thirst. The fetus experiences periods of sleep and wakefulness, but, unlike sleep and wakefulness in post-natal life, it does not occur in a changing environment, nor does it have much effect upon its environment. The intra-uterine environment presents fewer stimuli for arousal and quiescence or changes in state.

Once out of the womb, however, the infant is inundated by an environment that changes continuously. The ability of an infant to make transitions from one state to another (e.g., hunger/thirst, followed by feeding, followed by satiety) depends upon, for example, the infant’s temperament as well as the commitment, sensitivity, and skill of the mother.


Nutritional Aspects


Nutritional adequacy is comprised of a sequence of phenomena: (1) Adequate food must be available in the environment. (2) The child must take in adequate amounts of food. If food is not offered, older children can forage, but infants and toddlers depend entirely on their caregivers’ recognition of, and responses to their hunger signals. The dyadic relationship, of which feeding and eating is a major part, must work well enough to avoid feeding disorders that impair parents’ ability to feed and their infant’s ability to eat in a comfortable, satisfying manner. (3) Sufficient food must be retained and not regurgitated or vomited before it can be digested. (4) The food must be digested before it can be absorbed. A child with cystic fibrosis, for example, may grow poorly, even though he may eat more than normal amounts of food, because the pancreas fails to secrete enough enzymes to digest the food that enters her intestine. (5) The lining of the small intestine is the surface through which the products of digestion enter the bloodstream. If the area of this absorptive surface is reduced, as in celiac disease, weight gain and linear growth may be severely impaired. (6) As soon as the products of digestion have been absorbed, they may be utilized for growth. The presence of sufficient nutrients in the bloodstream promotes normal growth. However, severe physical and/or emotional stress can interfere with tissue-building and promote tissue wasting so that the nutrients available for incorporation into growing tissues are, instead, lost through the urine along with the waste products of normal metabolism.

This sequence of phenomena essential for growth is depicted in Table 7.1.


Table 7.1
Defective nurturing can impair growth and development at steps 1, 2, 3, and 6. Each defect has a distinct clinical pattern






































The sequence of nutrition and its impediments
 
The sequence

The impediments

Step 1

Food availability

Famine or starvation

Step 2

Ingestion of food

Infant feeding disorders:

Feeding disorder of state regulation

Feeding disorder of reciprocity

Infantile anorexia

Step 3

Retention of ingested food

Nervous Vomiting Syndrome

Infant Rumination Syndrome

Step 4

Digestion of food

Pancreatic insufficiency (e.g., cystic fibrosis)

Step 5

Absorption of the products of digestion

Celiac disease

Step 6

Assimilation of absorbed nutrients (anabolism and growth)

Failure of attachment


This table was published in The Encyclopedia of Infant and Early Childhood Development, Haith/Benson, pages 478–492, Copyright Elsevier, 2008

Irene Chatoor described six feeding disorders of infancy and early childhood [15], three of which are often associated with FTT: Feeding Disorder of State Regulation (onset during the first 2 months); Feeding Disorder of Reciprocity (onset between 2 and 6 months); and Infantile Anorexia (onset during the transition from bottle or breast to spoon and self-feeding).

During the first 2 months, successful feeding requires the infant to achieve a state of calm alertness. Infants who have difficulty with state regulation may be difficult to calm. Even though they may feel hungry, they may be unable to reach or maintain the necessary state of calm alertness or they may be too sleepy, too agitated or too easily distracted by stimuli in the environment to complete or even begin a feeding. The infant may fail to gain weight. As the mother becomes more worried, her ability to soothe her infant may deteriorate. A vicious cycle may become established, similar to the one that perpetuates “persistent colic” (see pp 140–141).

Feeding disorder of reciprocity has its onset beyond 2 months of age. An infant older than 2–3 months has the ability to respond to and initiate social interactions with its caregiver. The dyadic relationship includes communicative behaviors such as mutual smiling, cuddling with holding, and mutual vocalizations. Feeding is a major focus of mutually pleasurable engagement during which cognitive and emotional development accompanies physical satisfaction and growth. If, during this stage of development, the caregiver is unresponsive to the infant’s presence or signals, the infant may withdraw, become depressed, and fail to learn behaviors that foster nurturing. Instead of the social smile, he or she may avoid eye contact. Instead of cuddling and molding into a comfortable feeding position, he or she may be either stiff or limp. A caregiver’s failure to emotionally attach to her infant impairs the infant’s ability to become attached to the caregiver. It may become passive, lethargic, and disinterested in food [16]. In the absence of environmental stimulation, such infants tend to engage in self-stimulatory behaviors, such as head-rolling or rumination. Growth and development lag, malnutrition, and decreased resistance to infection may result in death of the infant or, if it survives, a damaged capacity to form attachments in later life.

Infant anorexia is another feeding disorder that may impair growth. Its onset occurs between 6 months and 3 years, a period during which the infant becomes increasingly able to function more independently and willfully. The offer of food by spoon normally becomes an interaction during which any discordant desires of toddler and mother need to be negotiated. This may be especially difficult in toddlers who, by temperament, are easily distracted. Feedings take too long. The parent tries harder to get food into the child’s mouth. Attempts to cajole or trick the child into taking food are met with refusal to open, refusal to swallow, turning away, throwing food or utensils, or climbing out of the high-chair. Parents become increasingly worried as the child who seems to never be hungry, is increasingly difficult to feed, and begins to lose weight. Chatoor found that “…difficult infant temperament was associated with higher mother-infant conflict during feeding…the most difficult infants demonstrated the highest levels of conflict and growth failure.”

Case Vignette: Infant Anorexia Syndrome [15]



  • A 13-month-old boy, the product of an unplanned pregnancy, was born to a 36-year-old mother of two teenage children. He was described as an “active baby” who had colic for the first 6 weeks. At about 4 months of age, the baby refused his formula. Different formulas were tried, but were taken poorly. Spoon feedings became difficult and he needed to be coaxed or forced to eat. He chewed food put into his mouth, but refused to swallow it. Weight gain continued along the 10th to 25th percentile channels until 1 month prior to being hospitalized at 13 months of age.


  • At the time he was hospitalized, his weight was below the 3rd percentile. He refused almost every food except apple juice. After gaining the mother’s acquiescence, we tested the premise that he would not feel hunger and that he would starve if left to feed himself without being fed by a caregiver. Accordingly, the infant was placed in a crib along with several bottles of milk and an abundance of finger foods, but no apple juice. Foods were freely available for the taking, but no feeding was attempted. His mother and other observers mostly remained out of the room. After drinking and eating nothing for almost 18 h, he reached for a grape, put it into his mouth, chewed, and swallowed it. After a minute or two, he began drinking milk and avidly eating the cookies, grapes, and other finger foods in his crib. During the remaining 4 days of hospitalization, meals consisted of finger foods placed on the tray of his high-chair. The dramatic improvement in his intake coupled with the unequivocal appearance of a weight gain trend made it easier for the mother to comply with our recommendations that she completely abstain from feeding him and, instead, provide food for him to feed himself. During a diagnostic interview, the father described his wife as “over-protective…even the older ones, if they miss lunch, she’s afraid they’re going to die.”


  • The baby was brought for a follow-up visit 12 days after his release from the hospital. His weight had risen from below the 3rd percentile to just below the 10th percentile. He was feeding himself 24 oz of milk a day plus meat, pasta, rice, and other finger foods. He was still active and distractible.


Specific Failure to Thrive Syndromes


FTT can occur in infants who eat more or less adequate amounts of food, but fail to retain what they have taken in. This is exemplified by two functional vomiting disorders of infancy: “Nervous Vomiting” and Infant Rumination Syndrome (IRS).

Before considering these two vomiting syndromes that impair growth, it is important to recognize that about 50 % or more of healthy infants repeatedly vomit or regurgitate during the first 6–18 months of life. This kind of vomiting in normal infants and has been termed “innocent vomiting” [5]. It may range from effortless regurgitation to projectile vomiting. Its main characteristics are that there is no associated pain, nausea, loss of appetite, or underlying organic disease. It does not respond to dietary, positional, or pharmacologic measures. It does not impair weight gain, presumably because, if feedings are given liberally, to satiety, the infant compensates for what has been lost by taking in more. Innocent vomiting resolves spontaneously by or before 12–18 months of age. It is an important consideration in infants who fail to thrive because innocent vomiting plus growth failure may be mistaken for organic disease (e.g., gastroesophageal reflux disease or GERD). This may result in failure to diagnose and treat existing FTT and, instead, impose stressful diagnostic tests in pursuit of nonexistent diseases.

Nervous vomiting” was described by the British physician, H.C. Cameron, in 1925 [17]. It is often associated with failure to thrive. It may mimic hypertrophic pyloric stenosis radiologically [5]. Nervous vomiting is a visceral reaction to stress or excitement causing the stomach’s motility to be functionally altered, delaying passage of food into the intestine. Food is retained in the stomach longer than normally, keeping it as a reservoir for vomiting. Infant–mother interaction becomes increasingly distressed as vomiting increases and weight lags. A vicious cycle becomes established as a result of a breakdown in the nurturing relationship which, in turn, causes irritability, vomiting, and feeding difficulties leading to FTT (see Fig. 7.1).

A310563_1_En_7_Fig1_HTML.gif


Fig. 7.1
The vicious cycle of nervous vomiting

Once suspected, the diagnosis of FTT associated with nervous vomiting can be made by a positive response to a therapeutic trial of comfort [5]. This includes simultaneous efforts to relieve both the infant’s and the parent’s distress. Cameron wrote that, “treatment, if it is to be successful, must aim not so much at controlling the vomiting as at allaying the nervous unrest” [17]. This begins a therapeutic process that heals the parent–infant relationship and is necessary for continued improvement beyond the period of clinical management.
< div class='tao-gold-member'>

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 28, 2016 | Posted by in GASTOINESTINAL SURGERY | Comments Off on Failure to Thrive

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access