Failure of autogenous vein maturation
Thrombosis
Inadequate arterial inflow
Impaired venous outflow
Infection
Hematoma, seroma, lymphocele
Pseudoaneurysms
Arterial steal (hand ischemia)
Venous hypertension (limb swelling)
High-output cardiac failure
Duplex Ultrasound Scanning
Instrumentation
A standard duplex ultrasound system is required for examination of hemodialysis access sites with high-resolution B-mode imaging, color-flow Doppler, and spectral waveform analysis. A selection of transducers with a choice of operating frequencies and “footprints” is necessary for scanning of the inflow arteries, the superficial venous or prosthetic conduit (segment to be cannulated for dialysis), and the outflow veins. These include a midrange-frequency linear array transducer (e.g., L7-4) for general applications and a high-frequency transducer (e.g., L12-5, L10-5 intraoperative, L15-7 intraoperative) for assessing superficial vessels. A small curved array transducer (e.g., C8-5) is excellent when scanning around the clavicle.
Examination Protocol
Prior to scanning, the autogenous vein or prosthetic graft should be palpated to detect the presence or absence of a “thrill”—the normal vibration felt over an access site produced by high-velocity fistula flow. The presence of a strong pulse without a thrill suggests a venous outflow obstruction. Using the thrill as a guide, the course of the vein or graft can be traced on the skin to help direct the duplex examination. Alternatively, a stethoscope can be used to detect a bruit over the course of the vein or graft. An operative report or diagram of the access site is also helpful in planning the access site evaluation. A dialysis access duplex examination is best performed on a non-dialysis day to avoid reduction in blood pressure as a potential source of error.
The duplex examination of a dialysis access site can be divided into three main parts: (1) arterial inflow, (2) conduit, and (3) central venous outflow (Table 23.2). Examination of the conduit is different for autogenous vein fistulas and prosthetic grafts. In an autogenous fistula, the conduit is the superficial vein to which the inflow artery is connected by a single anastomosis; however, with prosthetic grafts, the conduit is the graft itself, and there are two anastomoses to evaluate.
Table 23.2
Protocol for duplex examination of dialysis access sites
1. Arterial inflow |
Scan the subclavian and axillary arteries, documenting the presence of atherosclerosis or other abnormalities |
Scan the brachial, radial, and ulnar inflow arteries, documenting the peak systolic velocity prior to the anastomosis Record the velocity in the artery peripheral to the anastomosis to evaluate for steal |
2. Conduit |
A. Autogenous vein fistula |
Document the location of the fistula anastomosis and identify the involved artery and vein |
Measure the diameter of the anastomosis |
Record peak systolic velocity at the anastomosis |
Evaluate the forearm and/or upper arm outflow vein throughout its course for evidence of venous stenosis, thrombosis, or other abnormalities |
B. Prosthetic graft |
Identify the arterial anastomosis; record peak systolic velocity at the anastomosis |
Scan the proximal, mid, and distal segments of the graft, evaluating for patency and stenosis with spectral waveform analysis. Use B-mode and color-flow Doppler imaging to look for pseudoaneurysms and other anatomic defects |
Identify the venous anastomosis; record peak systolic velocity at the anastomosis. Evaluate for venous stenosis at and immediately distal to the anastomosis |
3. Central venous outflow |
Scan the innominate, subclavian (supra- and infraclavicular), and axillary veins, evaluating for central venous outflow obstruction (thrombosis or stenosis) |
Arterial Inflow
Arterial inflow may be inadequate due to atherosclerotic occlusive disease, dissection, or other arterial conditions that narrow the upper extremity arteries. Doppler spectral waveforms from the inflow artery to a widely patent autogenous fistula or prosthetic graft are characterized by increased peak systolic velocity (PSV) with low pulsatility (high diastolic flow)—features typical of a “low-resistance” flow pattern (Fig. 23.1a). However, with a poorly functioning or occluded access site, the inflow arteries will display a typical “high-resistance” multiphase flow pattern similar to that of a normal peripheral artery (Fig. 23.1b). Significant arterial stenosis at any level in the vasculature supplying the access site may reduce the pulsatility and PSV within the autogenous fistula or prosthetic graft and lead to access failure.
Fig. 23.1
(a) Spectral waveform from a brachial artery supplying a widely patent hemodialysis access site shows a low-resistance flow pattern characterized by a relatively high peak systolic velocity (PSV) of 170 cm/s and antegrade flow throughout diastole. (b) Spectral waveform from the brachial artery of a patient with an occluded access site shows a PSV of 51 cm/s with a high-resistance multiphasic flow pattern
The subclavian, axillary, brachial, radial, or ulnar arteries proximal to the access site should be evaluated for stenosis. Flow patterns in the native arteries distal or peripheral to the anastomosis should also be recorded to document distal perfusion to the hand. Distal to the arterial anastomosis, the flow waveform may return to a high-resistance pattern or it may show alternating or retrograde flow direction suggestive of an arterial steal, as discussed later in this chapter. Spectral waveforms for all PSV measurements should be obtained using a Doppler angle of 60° between the ultrasound beam and the vessel wall. If a 60° angle is not possible, a smaller angle is acceptable; however, larger angles approaching 90° should be avoided.
Conduit
Autogenous Vein. A direct surgical connection between an inflow artery and an autogenous vein requires a single anastomosis. Autogenous vein fistulas are most commonly created at the wrist (radiocephalic fistula), antecubital space (brachiocephalic fistula), or the upper arm (basilic vein transposition fistula). The cephalic vein is preferred because it is more superficial than the basilic vein. If the basilic vein is used, it is usually transposed and brought closer to the skin surface for accessibility. After scanning the arterial inflow, evaluation of an autogenous fistula continues with the arterial-venous anastomosis followed by the superficial venous outflow vessel.
The site of the anastomosis is identified and the adjacent artery and vein segments are scanned. The diameter of the arteriovenous anastomosis is measured and is typically in the range of 4–5 mm (Fig. 23.2), since larger diameters have a higher risk of causing an arterial steal. The PSV at the anastomosis is measured from Doppler spectral waveforms, recognizing that relatively high velocities are common at anastomotic sites followed by turbulence due to caliber change and angulation.
Fig. 23.2
(a) B-mode image of an arteriovenous anastomosis with a diameter of 3.5 mm. (b) Spectral waveform obtained at the anastomotic site with a peak systolic velocity (PSV) of 539 cm/s and spectral broadening indicating turbulent flow
Because high velocities are common at an arteriovenous anastomosis, one method of identifying anastomotic stenosis by duplex ultrasound is based on the PSV ratio (Vr) which is defined as the maximum PSV within the anastomosis divided by the PSV in the inflow artery approximately 2 cm proximal to the anastomosis. A Vr of 3.0 or greater and a PSV of 400 cm/s or greater are suggestive of a stenosis of at least 50 % diameter reduction at the anastomosis [8, 9]. However, B-mode confirmation of an intraluminal defect at the anastomosis should also be obtained, since the geometry of the vessels may cause a velocity increase without a true stenosis (Fig. 23.3).
Fig. 23.3
A peak systolic velocity of 659 cm/s is recorded at this arteriovenous anastomosis, which is consistent with a stenosis, although the actual velocities may be higher. A color bruit in the adjacent tissue is also suggestive of a stenosis
The main superficial venous outflow in an autogenous fistula is usually through either the cephalic or the basilic vein. The entire length of the outflow vein is evaluated with B-mode, color-flow Doppler, and Doppler spectral waveforms. B-mode imaging in long-axis and transverse views will help identify intraluminal defects such as thrombus, chronic webbing, a fibrotic valve, or caliber change (Fig. 23.4). Color-flow images may show aliasing along the length of the outflow vein which helps to quickly identify focal velocity increases signifying a possible stenosis. Doppler spectral waveforms are also obtained along the length of the outflow vein. Within the outflow vein of the fistula, PSV is typically in the range of 150–300 cm/s, although velocities are highly variable. Some laboratories use a twofold focal velocity increase (Vr of 2.0) with associated poststenotic turbulence as a threshold to indicate a significant stenosis within the autogenous vein fistula [9]. Occlusion is identified by the presence of intraluminal echoes with no obtainable color Doppler flow or Doppler spectral waveforms.
Fig. 23.4
B-mode images in long-axis (a) and transverse (b) views showing thrombus in the cephalic outflow vein of an access site. Peak systolic velocity (PSV) is 508 cm/s at the site of maximum luminal narrowing
Prosthetic Graft. Access sites created with prosthetic grafts have two anastomoses─arterial and venous─and may be created from a variety of materials, with expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) being the most common. The evaluation of a prosthetic graft can be considered in three parts: (1) the arterial anastomosis, (2) the prosthetic conduit, and (3) the venous anastomosis. A loop graft is often created to provide more access site lengths for cannulation. The arterial anastomosis is performed with the graft directed peripherally, and the graft then makes a loop coursing back centrally to the venous anastomosis. With a loop graft, the arterial and venous anastomoses are usually located at the same level in the upper extremity, typically near the antecubital fossa. A straight graft runs directly back toward the heart from the arterial anastomosis to the outflow vein, and the venous anastomosis is located more proximally in the upper extremity.
The duplex evaluation of a prosthetic graft continues after the inflow arteries are assessed, measuring the diameter of the arterial anastomosis and the maximum PSV at that site. As with autogenous vein conduits, high velocities are common at the arterial anastomosis of a prosthetic graft, and flow disturbances related to angulation are frequently present; however, the diameters of graft anastomoses are less variable than those of autogenous vein anastomoses. Although velocities at the anastomotic sites of prosthetic grafts are extremely variable, the general threshold criteria for stenosis listed previously for autogenous vein fistulas can be applied to grafts. A PSV of 400 cm/s or greater and a focal velocity increase with a Vr of 3.0 or greater are consistent with a significant (≥50 % diameter reduction) anastomotic stenosis [9].
An initial B-mode image evaluation of the prosthetic graft in transverse and long-axis views will identify any intraluminal abnormalities that may be masked by the color-flow display. Abnormalities in the soft tissues around the graft, such as fluid collections, may also be identified by B-mode imaging. Color-flow Doppler is helpful in detecting anatomic defects such as pseudoaneurysms (Fig. 23.5). The prosthetic graft should be examined throughout its length using the pulsed Doppler and spectral waveforms for focal increases in PSV which may be due to intraluminal thrombus, neointimal hyperplasia, or stenosis at a revision site. Velocities in prosthetic grafts are quite variable; however, some criteria for significant (≥50 % diameter reduction) stenosis that have been applied include a PSV of 300–400 cm/s or greater, end-diastolic velocity (EDV) of 240 cm/s or greater, and Vr of 2.0 or greater [8, 9].
Fig. 23.5
Color-flow Doppler image of a small pseudoaneurysm (solid arrow) originating from a cephalic outflow vein (dashed arrow) of an access site
Graft occlusion is suggested by the absence of a palpable thrill or audible bruit over the graft on physical examination. Duplex confirmation of graft occlusion is based on the presence of intraluminal echoes on B-mode imaging and absence of flow on Doppler spectral waveforms and color-flow Doppler (Fig. 23.6). Some synthetic graft materials, including PTFE, contain small amounts of air that impede the transmission of ultrasound for a period of time after implantation. This causes acoustic shadowing across the lumen of the graft and prevents direct interrogation by Doppler. In this situation, Doppler spectral waveforms from the adjacent inflow artery and outflow vein can provide indirect evidence of graft patency. With a patent prosthetic graft, the inflow artery will show a low-resistance flow pattern, and the flow pattern may return to a high-resistance waveform in the artery distal to the anastomosis.
Fig. 23.6
B-mode and color-flow Doppler images of an occluded prosthetic graft in long-axis (a) and transverse (b) views. Intraluminal echoes and lack of flow confirm the diagnosis of graft occlusion
The venous outflow anastomosis should be identified and its diameter and maximum PSV measured. A common site for a stenosis is at or just beyond the venous anastomosis of a prosthetic graft, as indicated by a focal velocity increase with poststenotic turbulence.
Central Venous Outflow
Duplex evaluation of the upper extremity outflow veins can provide information on the presence or absence of central venous obstruction as well as the status of the autogenous vein fistula or prosthetic graft. Obstruction in the central veins is a common finding in long-term dialysis access patients, particularly those with a history of multiple central venous catheters. The flow patterns in the innominate and subclavian veins provide indirect information about graft or fistula outflow. With a functioning access site, spectral waveforms from the innominate and subclavian veins will show “arterialized” pulsatility (Fig. 23.7); if the access site is occluded, the central vein flow pattern will be non-pulsatile and more phasic with respiration.
Fig. 23.7
(a), Spectral waveforms from the subclavian vein on the side of a well-functioning access site show “arterialized” pulsatility with minimal respiratory phasicity. (b) In a limb without an access site, spectral waveforms from the subclavian vein show respiratory phasicity along with some pulsatility, typical of normal upper extremity central veins
A central outflow vein stenosis produces a focal velocity increase in the “arterialized” vein segment. The peak vein velocity (PVV) ratio has been defined as the poststenotic velocity divided by the pre-stenotic velocity, and a value >2.5 has been shown to correlate with a central venous stenosis severe enough to result in a pressure gradient [10]. Some central venous occlusions may be difficult to visualize directly with duplex scanning due to their location under the clavicle or in the mediastinum. The presence of visible, well-developed venous collaterals around the shoulder is suggestive of a central vein stenosis or occlusion.
Interpretation and Reporting
The approach to performing and interpreting duplex ultrasound evaluations of hemodialysis access sites follows the same principles as other duplex examinations of peripheral arteries and veins. However, the access site evaluation presents unique challenges due to the variety of vascular anatomy involved and the difficulty in establishing specific threshold velocity criteria for stenosis due to the wide variability in the velocities encountered. Both absolute velocities and velocity ratios have been used as the basis for classifying the severity of stenosis associated with access sites. While it is difficult to set threshold criteria that can be strictly applied in all cases, some guidelines are summarized in Table 23.3.
Table 23.3
Classification of hemodialysis access site stenosis by duplex scanning