Complementary, Surgical, and Experimental Modalities for Management of Premature Ejaculation

 

Study design

Study size

Placebo?

Medication

Baseline IELT (mins)

Post treatment IELT (mins)

IELT increase

Abdel-Hamid et al. [13]

prospective, blinded, randomized, crossover study

31

No

clomipramine 25 mg

sertraline 50 mg

paroxetine 20 mg

sildenafil 50 mg

“squeeze” technique

1

4

3

4

15

3

3

2

3

14

2

Mathers et al. [23]

randomized prospective crossover study

49

No

sertraline 50 mg

vardenafil 10 mg

0.59

3.12

5.01

2.53

4.42

Wang et al. [24]

prospective, randomized, non-blinded trial

180

No

50 mg sildenafil

20 mg paroxetine

squeeze technique

1.09

1.11

1.06

6.2

4.9

2.8

5.11

3.79

1.74

Aversa et al. [25]

prospective, double-blind, placebo-controlled, cross-over study

42

Yes

vardenafil 10 mg

placebo

0.6

0.7

4.5

0.9

3.9

0.2

McMahon et al. [14]

double-blind, placebo-controlled, parallel group, flexible-dose study

157

Yes

sildenafil 50–100 mg

placebo

0.96

1.04

2.6

1.63

1.6

0.6

Salonia et al. [28]

prospective, randomized, non-blinded trial

80

No

paroxetine 10 mg (on demand 20 mg)

paroxetine 10 mg (on demand sildenafil 50 mg)

0.33

0.35

3.7 and 4.2 (3 & 6 months)

4.5 and 5.3 (3 & 6 months)

3.37 & 3.87

4.15 & 4.95

Mattos et al. [28]

prospective randomized double blind placebo controlled trial

60

Yes

tadalafil 20 mg + fluoxetine 90 mg

fluoxetine 90 mg + placebo

tadalafil 20 mg + placebo

double placebo capsules

0.83

0.94

0.82

0.83

5.6

3.89

3.1

1.13

4.77

2.95

2.28

0.3

Hosseini et al. [30]

prospective randomized

91

No

20 mg fluoxetine +20 mg fluoxetine on demand

20 mg fluoxetine + 50 mg sildenafil on demand

0.5

0.55

3.4, and 4.3 (2 & 4 month)

4.2 and 5.1 (2 & 4 month)

2.9 & 3.8

3.65 & 4.55






24.3.2 Sexological/Behavioral/Functional Approaches


The ‘conditioning’ hypothesis of Rowland and Motofei separates the physiological ejaculatory processes into “hardwired” (unchangeable) and “softwired” (amenable to modulation) central and peripheral networks. Although these “hard-wired” components might respond in a graded manner to external modulators, they themselves are not the primary source of the modulation. While it seems likely that men cannot willfully and directly change underlying neurobiological responses (e.g., receptor sensitivity, inhibitory postsynaptic potentials, neurotransmitter release, etc.) in order to affect their orgasmic response, intentional modification of arousal, libido or motivation may alter the triggers for ejaculation. This view argues that treatment of PE aimed at multiple levels of functioning will be self-enhancing and ultimately more effective in producing positive therapeutic outcomes than strategies relying solely on either psychological or biological approaches [32].


24.3.2.1 Standard Behavioral Therapy for PE


In 1956, Semans reported one of the first contemporary behavioral interventions for PE using a “stop-and-start” technique involving extravaginal stimulation of the penis until premonitory sensations of ejaculation occur. At the point of ejaculatory premonition, stimulation was stopped until the sensation resolved. In this fashion it was thought that the man would become conditioned to recognize and control signs of impending ejaculation during penetrative coitus [33]. It was reported that this intervention led to successful results in eight couples but these robust findings have not been convincingly replicated.

Masters and Johnson (1970) reported on the “squeeze” technique for PE; in this methodology the glans penis is withdrawn and forcefully compressed at high states of sexual arousal so as to “reset” arousal and permit continued penetrative intercourse after squeezing is complete. Masters and Johnson reported a 97.8 % cure rate for their clients but these results have not been replicated [34].

The behavioral techniques of Semans and Masters and Johnson for management of PE have been incorporated (with and without modifications) into the treatment lexicon of contemporary sexual therapists despite a general lack of published replication of results and long-term follow-up. More contemporary authors have advanced a number of novel interventions/modalities as adjunctive behavioral treatments.


24.3.2.2 Virtual Reality


Optale studied the efficiency of a 1-year program combining psychodynamic therapy and virtual reality for the treatment of PE (described as “primary”) in 50 men. Therapy included a cycle of 12 psychodynamic sessions over a 25 week period integrating an audio CD and helmet with miniature television screens. Projected on these screens was a specially designed program about the development of sexual identity using a virtual pathway through a forest and nonerotic film clips. Clinical followup was done after 6 and 12 months after the cycle. After 6 months, partial (IELT greater than 2 min on 2/3rds of intercourse episodes) and complete (IELT consistently greater than 2 min) positive response was 8 and 48 %, respectively. This improved to a 54 % rate of complete response at 1 year with no partial responders at that time point. Of note, 26 % of patients dropped out of therapy [35]. The duration and likely expense of this prolonged therapy make the cure rate disappointing; furthermore, the outcome measures are subjective and nonvalidated, the inclusion criteria are vague, and there is no control group. While psychotherapy is likely to be of benefit it is not clear from this study that inclusion of the virtual reality experience improved results.


24.3.2.3 Internet-Based Sex Therapy


Internet-based sex therapy for men with ED has been advocated as an easily accessible and cost-effective treatment. van LankVeld et al. tested whether internet-based sex therapy is superior to a waiting list in 40 men with self-diagnosed PE. Treatment was based on the sensate-focus model of Masters and Johnson, and supplemented with cognitive restructuring techniques. Internet-based treatment was not superior to waiting list for PE in latency to ejaculation and sexual desire [36]. These data are limited by lack of a genuine control group; however it is suggested that a personal relationship with the therapist is important in realizing benefit from psychotherapy.


24.3.2.4 Functional-Sexological Approach


Carufela hypothesized that the ejaculatory reflex as such cannot be controlled but sexual excitement can via reduction in muscular tension. In a prospective study of 36 couples with PE (reported IELT <2 min), a functional-sexological curriculum designed to teach men (n = 18) how to control sexual excitement was compared to standard behavioral treatment (including the squeeze and stop-and-start techniques as described above). Nine random couples from each arm of the study were kept on a waiting list and served as a “control group”. This functional-sexological approach relies on focused attention to “temporal, spatial, and energetic dimensions movements”, to variable muscular contractions, and speed of sexual activity before and during intercourse, and to use of sexual positions that require less muscular tension. Stopwatch IELT was 57, 472, and 491 s pre-intervention, post-intervention, and at three-month followup, respectively, in the behavioral treatment arm. Stopwatch IELT was 43, 467, and 413 s pre-intervention, post-intervention, and at three-month followup, respectively, in the functional-sexological arm. Differences in IELT were statistically significant from baseline for both groups with no significant differences between the two treatment arms at followup [37]. Limitations of this method include difficulty mastering physical skills, which may require more effort and time than the traditional methods, as well as lack of clarity regarding presence of comorbid sexual concerns at baseline. Furthermore, the wait list group does not represent a true control.


24.3.2.5 Yoga


Yoga is a collection of physical and mental disciplines originating in India that have become a popular form of exercise and/or spiritual practice around the world [38]. Yoga has been purported as useful in the management of a number of health concerns including problems pertaining to sex. Dhikav et al. conducted a prospective, nonrandomized study of daily yoga or fluoxetine daliy dose in 68 patients with PE. In these men, PE was diagnosed based on DSM-IV criteria, which stipulate only that ejaculation occurs before it is desired with no specific time criteria. Asanas (yoga positions) for this study were selected for their general putative health benefits with a focus on postures thought to improve muscle tone and plasticity of the pelvic and perineal muscles. Both groups had significant (p < 0.001) improvement in IELT 8 weeks after initiation of treatment although the degree of increase was greater in the fluoxetine group (30 s at baseline increased to 64 s at followup in the yoga arm vs. 33 s at baseline increased to 113 s at followup in the fluoxetine arm) [38]. This patient population was recruited from an outpatient psychiatric clinic which could limit its applicability; furthermore, the lack of placebo control and randomization complicates interpretation of results.


24.3.2.6 Physical Therapy


La Pera proposed pelvic floor rehabilitation as a therapeutic modality for PE; his program involved physiokinesitherapy, electrostimulation of the external sphincter to induce hypertrophy, and biofeedback to control the ejaculatory reflex which reinforces and tones muscles thought to inhibit the reflex contractions of ejaculation. The trio of interventions is suggested to increase the closing pressure of the external urethral sphincter and possibly delay ejaculation. A prospective study of eighteen patients with PE (defined as ejaculation within 1 min or 15 vaginal strokes) and normal penile nocturnal tumescence testing evaluated the effects of 15–20 sessions of this program of pelvic floor rehabilitation for PE. Of the eighteen patients, eleven were cured by learning to “control the reflex”, although the precise definition of cure was not reported [39]. The lack of clearly defined endpoints and failure of replication, tend to detract credibility from this manuscript. Furthermore, 15 patients were reported to have had PE for longer than 5 years but it is unclear how many had lifelong versus acquired PE.


24.3.3 Acupuncture


Sunay assessed acupuncture for PE (IELT <2 min) compared to daily paroxetine and sham acupuncture. Ninety men with PE received either 20 mg of daily paroxetine, twice weekly acupuncture (with points chosen based on standard acupuncture practice), or twice weekly sham acupuncture (placement of a needle at the same point as the treatment group without skin penetration to produce a “pricking” sensation) for 4 weeks (= 30 each arm). Men with primary PE made up about 2/3rds of the study cohort and were evenly distributed between treatment arms. IELT was measured for each individual man and mean rank IELT was determined. Paroxetine produced the longest mean-rank increase in IELT at 83 s compared to 66 s in the acupuncture arm and 33 s in the sham arm. The difference between both paroxetine and acupuncture arms was significantly greater than what was observed in the control arm [40]. This manuscript is limited in that men with both secondary and primary PE were enrolled. However, these data suggest that acupuncture may exert an effect on IELT but this effect appears to be less than what is observed with medical therapy. Further investigations of this modality may be warranted.


24.3.4 Herbal Medications


Herbal therapies are an increasingly popular treatment for a variety of health concerns, including issues pertaining to sexuality [41]. These treatments may be preferred by individuals who cannot afford prescription medications, individuals who prefer a naturopathic approach to health, and individuals who are mistrustful of prescribed pharmaceuticals. Herbals and nutraceuticals are not regulated by the FDA or other international regulatory agencies and there has been substantial concern about irregularities (contamination, counterfeiting, intentional or accidental mislabeling) of over -the-counter herbal drugs [41]. Nevertheless, these compounds may in some cases have utility in the management of sexual concerns including PE.

Satureja montana (winter savory) is a medicinal plant traditionally used to treat disorders including male sexual dysfunction. Zavattia et al. evaluated the effect of the plant’s hydroalcoholic extract, given acutely and subacutely, on copulatory behavior of sexually potent male rats. Groups of 5–7 animals were given 0 mg, 25 or 50 mg/kg of the extract acutely (testing 45 min post-dose) and subacutely (testing after eight once daily treatments) for: mount latency; intromission latency; ejaculation latency; postejaculatory interval; mount frequency; intromission frequency. Acute administration of Satureja montana extract significantly increased ejaculation latency and reduced the number of intromissions before ejaculation without affecting the percentage of animals achieving ejaculation (100 % in all experimental groups) [42]. While the results are interesting it is not clear that these findings are applicable to the human condition of PE; further human studies are required. Gu-jing-mai-si-ha is an herbal compound consisting of Radix anacycli pyrethri, Mastiche, Fructus Cardamomi, Rhizoma Cyperi, Stigma Croci, Semen Myristicae, Radix Curcumae, Folium Syringae oblatae, Radix et Rhizoma Nardostachyos, Fructus Tsaoko, and Flos Rosae rugosae. It has been hypothesized that this decoction may treat PE by modulation of smooth muscle necessary for ejaculation. Song investigated the effect of gu-jing-mai-si-ha tablets (administered as 4 tablets of unspecified dose twice daily for 15 days) for treatment of primary and secondary PE (IELT <2 min, no specifics on how many primary vs. secondary) in a randomized prospective trial of 69 patients. A comparison group of patients who were not treated with any intervention was included. Evaluation of response was conducted at baseline and “at the end of the treatment period” although it is not clarified if this was on the day of the last dose. Mean IELT improved from 1.27 to 2.73 min in the treatment group compared to a change of mean IELT from 1.25 to 1.16 min in the untreated group. Serum level of NO and PGF2α increased significantly in the treated group; the authors speculate that this effect may be responsible for the change in IELT [43]. Limitations of this study include unclear enrollment criteria and clinical endpoints, lack of a true placebo control group, unclear means of calculating IELT, and difficulty in determination of the active moiety of this complex herbal extract.


24.3.5 Surgical Approaches


It has been speculated that enhanced sensitivity of the glans penis may account for some cases of PE [44]. Indeed, modulation of penile sensitivity is the underlying principle for topical anesthetics in the management of PE [6, 8]. While reversible modulation of penile sensitivity is within the bounds of standard of care, some authors have investigated surgical approaches to permanently decrease glanular sensitivity and in so doing prolong ejaculatory latency.


24.3.5.1 Circumcision


The role of human foreskin on sexual sensitivity and satisfaction is a topic of vociferous debate despite the absence of convincing data that the foreskin is either essential or nonessential for optimal sexual satisfaction, specifically as it pertains to ejaculatory latency [4551]. Both removal and/or restoration of the foreskin and frenulum have been touted as potential solutions to disorders of ejaculation.

Waldinger conducted a prospective study of 491 heterosexual couples recruited from the United States, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, Spain, and Turkey to determine the stopwatch-assessed IELT over a 4-week period in a random cohort of men who had not presented nor been diagnosed with a sexual problem. The overall median value was 5.4 min but with differences between countries; interestingly and contrary to popular belief about early ejaculation as a young men’s sexual problem, IELT was lower in progressively older age cohorts. The median IELT did not differ significantly based on circumcision status when subjects from Turkey (n = 130, all of whom had been circumcised) were excluded (6.7 min in circumcised vs. 6.0 min in uncircumcised European and American men) [45]. While this study was not a prospective analysis of circumcision and its’ influence on ejaculatory function, it is suggested that presence of absence of the foreskin does not substantially influence ejaculatory latency.

In a retrospective study, Masood assessed the effect of circumcision for benign disease (most commonly Balanitis xerotica obliterans, nonspecific inflammation, or phimosis) on sexually active men without ED as determined by the abridged, five item version of the International Index of Erectile Function (IIEF-5). Of 150 men who had undergone circumcision, 84 (59 %) responded. Fifty-four of these subjects (64 %) did not report PE (in response to a single- item nonvalidated question about presence or absence of PE) at any time point. Of the remaining 30 patients, 16 (53 %) reported no change in ejaculation, 4 (13 %) reported improvement in PE, and = 10 (33 %) reported worsening of PE after circumcision [47]. This study is limited by the lack of a uniform definition of what constitutes PE as well as potential for recall bias regarding ejaculatory function. All of these men had a benign condition of the penis, most often inflammatory, and the influence of that condition on sexual and ejaculation function may have strongly influenced outcomes. The followup interval is not made clear in this report.


24.3.5.2 Frenulectomy


Gallo et al. hypothesized that the presence of a short frenulum is associated with primary PE and that treatment of this condition may improve ejaculatory latency. In a cohort study of 137 patients with primary PE (defined here as “ejaculation which always or nearly always occurs prior to or within about 1 min of vaginal penetration, and the inability to delay ejaculation”), 59 (43 %) were found to have a “short frenulum”. The authors defined a short frenulum as “every case in which, applying a gentle pressure, the length of the frenulum restricted the movement of the prepuce, causing, during its complete retraction, a ventral curvature of the glans major of 20”. Forty patients with short frenulum and PE underwent total excision of the frenulum and coagulation of the proximal stump. Mean IELT was 1.6 min at baseline and 4.1 min at a mean followup time of 7 ± 3 months [52]. Limitations of this study include use of arithmetic rather than geometric mean IELT, short followup of only 7 months, lack of a control group, and somewhat arbitrary definition as to what constitutes a short frenulum. Surgical intervention for PE may pose significant risks and should be undertaken with extreme caution [53].


24.3.5.3 Glans Injections


Glanular injection of bulking agents with the intention of partially disrupting sensation of the glans penis has been advanced as a treatment for PE. The concept is similar in principle to on-demand use of topical anesthetics although in this circumstance the desire is to permanently decrease the density and/or responsiveness of nerve innervations to the glans.

Hyaluronan (HA) is a naturally occurring polysaccharide that is ubiquitous in the extracellular matrix of many animal species including humans. Kim et al. investigated the effects of partial dorsal neurotomy (transection of the dorsal component of the glanular innervations and the ventral and lateral component of the contralateral glanular innervations through a circumcising incision, n = 25), glanular augmentation with injectable HA (subcutaneous injection of 2 ml of HA near the corona of the glans in a fanned-out fashion with supplemental HA injections to smooth out undulations, n = 65), and dorsal neurotomy with glanular augmentation (n = 49) in nonrandomized patients with lifelong PE. Criteria for enrollment were not clearly specified but mean IELT (method of ascertainment not specified) for all groups was less than 2 min (mean baseline range 25–210 min). Six months after treatment, mean IELT was significantly increased in all three groups (89–236 s in the dorsal neurotomy group, 97–282 s in the glans augmentation group, and 102–324 s in the combination treatment group). There was no significant difference in mean IELT between treatment groups although there was a higher rate of adverse events (numbness, paresthesias) in patients who underwent dorsal neurotomy as single or combination therapy. Patient and partner satisfaction was relatively similar between treatment groups [54].

In a subsequent publication by these same authors, Kwak et al. followed up the 5-year outcome of HA injection in 38 of the initial cohort of 65 patients treated with HA injection monotherapy. Followup mean IELT (measured by stopwatch) was high at 352 s (range 220–410 s) compared to baseline mean IELT (84 s with range 45–170 s). The mean IELT was slightly but significantly less at 5 years compared to 6 months; however, the absolute difference was small at 25 s [55].

These studies are limited in that PE is not clearly defined, there is no control group, and it is not specified how patients were assigned to treatment groups. Furthermore, it is not clear whether the patients without 5-year followup data were lost or had simply not reached the 5 year point. A randomized controlled trial with more precisely defined inclusion criteria and endpoints is required before this treatment can be considered anything but experimental.


24.3.5.4 Radiofrequency Ablation of the Dorsal Penile Nerves


Basal et al. investigated bilateral neuromodulation of the dorsal penile nerves by pulsed radio frequency in 15 men with lifelong PE (IELT <1 min) refractory to medical management and no ED based on the IIEF-EF (no specifics given). Neuromodulation of this sort is intended to apply high voltage adjacent to a nerve without inducing injury and has been utilized in pain management. Baseline mean geometric IELT was 19 s; at followup 3 weeks later mean IELT was 140 s. During extended follow-up (mean of 8.3 ± 1.9 months) “none of the patients or their wives reported any treatment failure” but no additional IELT measurements were obtained and the definition of treatment failure is not provided. The procedure was by report painless [56]. The study is limited by small cohort size, lack of a control group and very short follow-up using the gold standard of IELT assessment. The potential for long-term damage to sensory capacity must also be considered.


24.3.5.5 Summary Statement on Surgical Approaches for PE


While it is difficult to conduct controlled and randomized studies of surgical interventions for PE, the lack thereof constitutes a serious limitation of current studies. The relatively permanent nature of this sort of intervention makes careful patient counseling and further studies essential to determine if there is any utility from these approaches. At the present time, there are insufficient data to justify surgical management of PE.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jul 17, 2017 | Posted by in UROLOGY | Comments Off on Complementary, Surgical, and Experimental Modalities for Management of Premature Ejaculation

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access