Overall Bottom Line
- LT, by necessity, subjects the liver allograft to ischemia followed by reperfusion.
- The pattern and severity of IRI that ensues may be clinically irrelevant in the majority of the cases; however, IRI may cause a spectrum of liver dysfunction resulting in DGF or PNF.
- The clinical consequences of IRI may range from prolonged length of stay, post-operative complications, re-transplantation, and ultimately recipient death.
- Recent research has elucidated many molecular pathways involved in hepatic IRI; however, only a few experimental interventional modalities currently exist.
Section 1: Background
Definition of disease
- IRI is a pathologic state characterized by:
- Ischemic phase injury resulting in significant reduction of microcirculatory blood flow on reperfusion, perpetuating ischemic injury.
- Inflammatory response, activated during the ischemic phase (initiated by Kupffer cells), which is amplified during the reperfusion phase.
- Hepatocyte injury and death occurring via inflammatory response (neutrophil activation, complement activation, T cell-mediated apoptosis), as well as directly via ROS resulting in perturbation of ionic homeostasis, depletion of ATP, mitochondrial permeability and transition.
- Distant organ dysfunction (cardiovascular, lung, kidney) may occur as a direct consequence of hepatic IRI.
- Ischemic phase injury resulting in significant reduction of microcirculatory blood flow on reperfusion, perpetuating ischemic injury.
- Therefore, IRI is the pathologic state behind DGF and PNF, regardless of cause.
- However, the terminology of IRI is often used to describe the clinical state of DGF where no obvious etiology (i.e. vascular thrombosis) can be identified – therefore, it is a diagnosis of exclusion!
Disease classification
- Normal graft function after LT is characterized by:
- Intraoperative restoration of hemostasis.
- Stabilization of hemodynamics.
- Rapid resolution of encephalopathy.
- Normalization of INR within 24 hours.
- Decrease in AST and ALT within 24–48 hours (AST before ALT, AST t½ ∼18 hours, ALT t½ ∼48 hours).
- Delayed decrease in bilirubin within 48–72 hours.
- Intraoperative restoration of hemostasis.
- DGF is a clinical state characterized by:
- Delayed restoration of hemostasis.
- Delayed stabilization of hemodynamics – may require transient inotropic support.
- Delayed resolution of encephalopathy.
- Delayed normalization of INR.
- Increase in AST and ALT during the first 24–48 hours, followed by decrease.
- Delayed restoration of hemostasis.
- PNF = post-operative fulminant hepatic failure:
- Complete lack of hemostasis, requiring blood product support.
- Hemodynamic instability, requiring inotropic support.
- Unresolving encephalopathy.
- Multisystem organ failure ensues.
- Continual rise in LFT, bilirubin and lactic acidosis.
- Massive graft necrosis.
- Complete lack of hemostasis, requiring blood product support.
Incidence/prevalence
- Although IRI is a relatively frequent clinical phenomenon in LT, little is known about the incidence of DGF, probably because it is not reported. The incidence of PNF is about 5%.
Etiology
- LT, by necessity, subjects the liver graft to ischemia followed by reperfusion. The transplant liver graft undergoes three phases of ischemia:
- Warm ischemia – donor ischemic events (codes, “down time”) and in donation after cardiac death, from extubation to aortic cross-clamp.
- Cold ischemia – during cold preservation, from cross-clamp until off ice.
- Warm ischemia – during vascular anastomoses, from off ice until reperfusion.
- Warm ischemia – donor ischemic events (codes, “down time”) and in donation after cardiac death, from extubation to aortic cross-clamp.
- During cold ischemia, sinusoidal endothelial cells are vulnerable, while hepatocytes are relatively protected. During warm ischemia, all cell types are vulnerable; thus, cold ischemia is better tolerated than warm ischemia.
Pathology/pathogenesis
Perfusion abnormality during reperfusion worsens ischemic injury
- Lack of oxygen results in failure of ATPase, leading to intracellular swelling.
- Increase in vasoconstrictors (endothelin and thromboxane A2) and decrease in vasodilators (nitric oxide).
- Results in sinusoidal narrowing.
- During reperfusion, platelet and neutrophil adhesion and sinusoidal narrowing result in reduction of microcirculatory blood flow leading to some areas without reperfusion (“no-reflow”).
Inflammatory activation leads to hepatocyte injury
- Kupffer cells initiate inflammatory cascade during the ischemic phase – releasing pro-inflammatory cytokines (TNF-α and IL-1β) – recruiting CD4+ lymphocytes during reperfusion, which in turn recruit neutrophils via IL-17.
- Natural killer cells and platelets are recruited; sinusoidal endothelial cells and hepatocytes are activated.
- Complement pathways are activated leading to membrane attack complex formation.
- Toll-like receptor 4 are activated on Kupffer cells and dendritic cells by danger-associated molecular patterns, resulting in further release of pro-inflammatory cytokines (TNF-α and IL-1β via MyD88 dependent pathway) and IP-10 (leukocyte chemoattractant via MyD88 independent pathway).
ROS cause direct hepatocyte injury
- Kupffer cells release ROS.
- ROS cause oxidative damage to hepatocyte membrane lipids, enzyme complexes of the respiratory chain and DNA.
- ROS injury causes further release of ROS from nearby hepatocyte mitochondria (known as ROS-induced ROS release), self-propagating mitochondrial damage.
- Ionic homeostasis of hepatocyte Ca2+, Na+ and H+ is perturbed.
- Mitochondrial Ca2+ overload and ATP depletion result in increased permeability of inner mitochondrial membrane via mitochondrial permeability transition.
- When the majority of mitochondria undergo mitochondrial permeability transition, hepatocyte necrosis ensues.
Predictive/risk factors
Donor factors
- Older donors >60 years. May be explained by decreased expression of protective factors (i.e. Nrf2) in older donors.
- Graft macrovesicular steatosis >30%.
- Other underlying liver disease.
- Donation after cardiac death.
Operative factors
- Poor flushing during procurement.
- Mottled reperfusion: may be intraoperative evidence of “no-reflow.”
- Increased cold ischemia time.
- Increased warm ischemia time. Higher risk than cold ischemia.
Recipient factors
- Underlying sepsis.
Section 2: Prevention
Bottom Line/Clinical Pearls